Dies to Removal

WitchHunt

He's been pretty swamped with work. I've been talking to him about shit for the last few days, I'll try texting him.

WitchHunt

Yeeeeeah. I was pretty upset about the imopen lynch, especially when there were obviously way better choices.

WitchHunt

I was trying to hold on to my ability as sort of an ace in the hole, which I now regret, I kind of figured if I made it apparent I could Planeswalk with a higher chance toward a plane I wanted I'd get targeted by scum pretty quickly. That didn't work out so hot haha. The Necromancer chat was probabl...

WitchHunt

Rez is town. Your confirmed town should consist of Pedro, Ham, and Rez.

WitchHunt

Manders, WhitcHunt got NightKilled :lol: He's town, he was Karn Dammit, that explains that. He WAS around. Why didn't he say anything, dammit! I mentioned a couple times I was fairly sure there were going to be multiple walks in game. In regards to imopen? He wasn't even lynched because of lack of ...

WitchHunt

There's no reason to believe it was a one shot unless it was yours. I could use my secondary walk once per day.

WitchHunt

Well, I guess there's no negative really at this time, but I'd rather get his role info.

WitchHunt

Imopen needed the prod, figured it was safe to start there while I did a reread of him and RCW. I also figured I'd see who would be quick to jump on the wagon for a hopefully quick and easy lynch. Mid read caught a few things I kind of breezed over before, after ISO'ing LMD I'm seeing things I don't...

WitchHunt

The bit with you confirming Ham? Has me wary, but I'll go with it for now. Think with your brain on how I would confirm ham Because I am thinking with my brain is partly why I'm wary? Could be a couple of things. And in case you didn't see it, scumbag is confirmed town right now And I didn't see it...

WitchHunt

I had asked Manders to confirm the neighbor thing since she was able to speak as some extra verification.

In regards to the planeswalk, I'm in.

Planeswalk

The bit with you confirming Ham? Has me wary, but I'll go with it for now.

WitchHunt

deadguys can confirm rezombad is town, so I do. rezombad is town by way of ability rules.

How exactly are you confirming Rez is town?

While we're here, we may as well get Mander's to confirm there was only one neighbor and it was Ham.

@Rez TubeHunter was the Bodyguard.

WitchHunt

I would've been fine with Innistrad. I feel like we already have a pretty reasonable foundation at the moment, I think Ria's plan doesn't need to really keep going. Knowledge about the other planes is solid, but it's not as essential at this point. In regards to the Planeswalk, I can understand Rezo...

WitchHunt

That aside, what are we doing, I feel there is a solid case on scumbag, is there anyone Im missing, what do?
What's the case against scumbag? I must've missed it.

Seconded, the case against him was super minor imo. Maybe he knows something we don't?

WitchHunt

With this said Planeswalking is the way to go. First it makes for a fun game, second, as town we can glean some more info, think Serra's realm. Plus, reading the OP, if we can get to Grixis, we might bring back a zombie Manders, no idea how this works, but it seems we have a limited capability to r...

WitchHunt

Well, we're not lynching Scumbag, we've got at least one confirmed townie, with things slowing down how about we step back into the old plan a bit and Planeswalk to spice things up a bit?

WitchHunt

still on V:LA but people, please read the mafia wiki definition of neighbor. I don't understand how you can confirm Ham as town?!? Ham, was Manders your only neighbor? After reading through the wiki, this is relevant. If there was only two in their "neighborhood" shouldn't that add suppor...

WitchHunt

That's fine, I'm not too worried about it. :rolleyes2: Gentlemen, I have returned! I was Manders' neighbor. Totally missed this, I apologize. Guess that's what happens when I don't read in zombie mode from work. So if true, Ham is basically confirmed town, Tubehunter as a bodyguard could be good for...

WitchHunt

Hm. Looking back on it, Scumbag's right. We don't have a real reason to ask for his claim other than a wagon vote over a statement construed as rolefishing. My vote's going to stay off him, I'm going to reread just to make sure once I get back from work, but it doesn't feel right to me.

WitchHunt

You didn't submit a target or you submitted and Stardust told you to go fish?
Witchhunt, answer this.

I didn't submit a target, it was already two days into the night when I went to double check.

WitchHunt

This day was slow then took off like crazy. Mander's neighbor claim is still relevant, but Scumbag need's to claim first. I like how he ignores everyone's accusations and pushes for the Planeswalk plan, I suppose there's not much to defend with, but still.

WitchHunt

I fucked up and misread the ability. I thought it was for night, so I didn't submit a target for it. In regards to the NK, I'm behind Scumbug with this one. It comes off as random to me, especially since Manders was on Tubehunter pretty hardcore. If he's actually a Bodyguard then no one really has a...

WitchHunt

Jeeeeeesus Christ. Let's see here. So the gist of it, Tubehunter is always super concerned when he gets voted, showed a ton of indecision towards the Planeswalking plan in the first place then just suddenly decided to go with it, has several classic scum tells from what I think I'm understanding her...

WitchHunt

I would. Scum wants to figure out what the planes do just as much as town does. If we figure out what all planes do, scum would be at an advantage because of their scum/town knowledge. Does Kpaca's plan make him scum though? No, it's too early to tell.

WitchHunt

In regards to the role fishing, finding out that information is more beneficial to scum early on than town imo.

I understand the curiosity between what the Mafia members mmpf bit could actually be, but I personally believe that plane should just be avoided. I'd just rather not risk it.

WitchHunt

Vote: Kpaca Just kind of a gut feeling for now. The reaction toward everyone walking away from Dominaria is a bit much imo, the Planeswalk was going to happen. It bled into his "now I'm just going to be a vanilla" statement pretty well, whether it's true or not I'm not sure yet. When Kpac...

WitchHunt

I'd prefer to do it privately. I'll take suggestions on as the end of the day gets closer, but I'm not going to say who I'm going to do it to. I'll more than happily reveal the info on the next day with my reasoning as well, I just feel telling who I'm going to do it to before hand has too many issu...

WitchHunt

Well, the game picked up quite a bit since the last time I checked. Jesus Christ.

Planeswalk

Hopefully this shit earlier is behind us.

WitchHunt

I do agree with his statement that Innistrad was a strong pro town Plane, it would've been a fine place to stop. I kind of like how Rezombad was shooting for that Plane regardless early in the game, but I'm pretty sure that's just a huge coincidence. I guess we'll wait to see what the new Plane is, ...

WitchHunt

Oh and innistrad. I don't have any abilities on any planes as some of you apparently do, I just thought it would be cool. Vote1 rezombad Vote2 rezombad Sorry Ham, I do think it's a bit dumb. :/ Probably, but I figured that we're here so I might as well try to make use of the plane's rules. Understa...

WitchHunt

Under normal circumstances any player would planeswalk away if they were going to die, town or not imo (If they haven't walked already that is). Is that really considered scum bait?

WitchHunt

You guys are assholes, not even what I said. -.-

/in
Ral Zarek
Karn
Sorin

WitchHunt

It's no worries duder, shit happens haha. You did great, can't say I'd have pulled off as much as you did.

WitchHunt

WitchHunt

Yeah, I agree wholeheartedly. It caught me off guard too, I can see the confusion it brought on.

WitchHunt

It was incredibly useful imo. Having a second opinion on certain choices was pretty solid.

WitchHunt

No point anymore, just do your votes and get it over with.

WitchHunt

WitchHunt: What do you mean by my involvement with the initial murder? That was my interpretation of it, it was phrased "Hamfactorial is innocent of the murder". Putting a little more thought into it, I figure it was phrased this way to avoid me catching DK with my one shot cop ability. W...

WitchHunt

WitchHunt: How does your cop ability work? You were labeled specifically as Innocent. He won't. I may as well come out and say it, I'm a JOAT. I copped Ham on day one, but I didn't have to say anything to confirm him as town and give up info about my role. Last night I doc'd Rezombad since Jamie fl...

WitchHunt

So you think rezombad executed the kill and you saved his life from kpaca's bomb? imopen, could you please detail how kpaca's bomb role worked? Yes, that's what I think happened. I've had my suspicions after seeing Kpaca's flip so I've been wary. You weren't sure when you could use your vig shot. A...

WitchHunt

He won't. I may as well come out and say it, I'm a JOAT. I copped Ham on day one, but I didn't have to say anything to confirm him as town and give up info about my role. Last night I doc'd Rezombad since Jamie flipped town and he was the only one who was on his side, come Day 3, apparently Kpaca's ...

Dies to Removal

Search found 227 matches

Game Hosting List

Planechase Mafia - Game Over

Planechase Mafia - Game Over

Planechase Mafia - Day 4 - Legacy's Legacy

Planechase Mafia - Day 4 - Legacy's Legacy

Planechase Mafia - Day 4 - Legacy's Legacy

Planechase Mafia - Day 3 - If There's Something Strange...

Planechase Mafia - Day 3 - If There's Something Strange...

Planechase Mafia - Day 3 - If There's Something Strange...

Planechase Mafia - Day 3 - If There's Something Strange...

Planechase Mafia - Day 3 - If There's Something Strange...

Planechase Mafia - Day 2 - Deadline May 26

Planechase Mafia - Day 2 - Deadline May 26

Planechase Mafia - Day 2 - Into Darkness

Planechase Mafia - Day 2 - Supreme Verdict

Planechase Mafia - Day 2 - Supreme Verdict

Planechase Mafia - Day 2 - Supreme Verdict

Planechase Mafia - Day 2 - Supreme Verdict

Planechase Mafia - Day 2 - Supreme Verdict

Planechase Mafia - Day 2 - Supreme Verdict

Re: Planechase Mafia - Day 2 - Quick! Teleport a heart into this guy!