Planechase Mafia - Game Over

[Col. Khaddafi]

Guess what my intention was with blatantly scummy posts like that and two other ones I made D1 that went uncommented?

"I was posting scummy stuff, but that was actually a scheme to bait real scum"

[Stardust]

You are currently on Alara, at Naya.

Votecount

Col. Khaddafi (2): ( G_R ), rcwraspy
( G_R ) (1): Pedrobear

Not voting: Mcdonalds, hamfactorial, RedNihilist, rezombad, Col. Khaddafi

With 8 alive, it's 5 to lynch.

[rezombad]

now channeling the ghost of manders so listen up

You guys need to slow the hell down and think about what you are doing.
There are 5 dead Townies. 8 players left alive. Almost certainly 3 of them are scum. Which makes the game 5/3. ERGO you are in LyLo. Remove the votes and produce WELL-EXPLAINED town/scum lists, ALL OF YOU.

Hi Ham. I miss chatting with you.

[Mcdonalds]

(OOG: going out of town tomorrow, may not be on for a couple of days)

[rcwraspy]

unvote

[hamfactorial]

now channeling the ghost of manders so listen up

You guys need to slow the hell down and think about what you are doing.
There are 5 dead Townies. 8 players left alive. Almost certainly 3 of them are scum. Which makes the game 5/3. ERGO you are in LyLo. Remove the votes and produce WELL-EXPLAINED town/scum lists, ALL OF YOU.

Hi Ham. I miss chatting with you.

[rcwraspy]

No offense but "cause he said so" at this point isn't rly good enough

At this point, huh? So up to this point, where's your contribution? A quick iso of you and you're probably the heaviest lurker in the game, and that's coming from someone who hasn't been able to post much in the last couple weeks. If you say taking a confirmed townie's advice isn't good enough right now, then why don't you tell me who's top of your scum list and why.

[Col. Khaddafi]

What the hell? Just because he is confirmed townie his words are gospel? He can't be wrong?

How about we stop doing all this "because he said so" crap and actually do what Manders suggested?

Also checking who voted for who and when in the past days. But I know, it will require, like, investment in the game

[rezombad]

So, I lost all my abilities for the next day and night, all I can do is vote

Tell me about your night

[rezombad]

I would love to see a well thought out t/s list from mcdonalds

[Col. Khaddafi]

So, I lost all my abilities for the next day and night, all I can do is vote

Tell me about your night

Yes I have a night ability

I would love to see a well thought out t/s list from mcdonalds

Seconded. Followed by G_R, rednihilist and rcwraspy who are some of the heaviest lurkers of this game

[rezombad]

Tell me of your dreams last night

[( G_R )]

From town to scum:

Pedro
rezombad
hamfactorial
Mcdonalds
RedNihilist
rcwraspy
Col. Khaddafi

[( G_R )]

Ah unvote

[Mcdonalds]

No offense but "cause he said so" at this point isn't rly good enough

At this point, huh? So up to this point, where's your contribution? A quick iso of you and you're probably the heaviest lurker in the game, and that's coming from someone who hasn't been able to post much in the last couple weeks. If you say taking a confirmed townie's advice isn't good enough right now, then why don't you tell me who's top of your scum list and why.

Calling someone a lurker whilst outing yourself as one isn't the wisest of actions

As for my T/S list (assuming the model suggested by Rezmanders)
Town:
Rezombad - at times the only one actively driving the game, pro active and trying to progress the game
Ham - I'm bad at reading him but he seems town
Pedro - mod confirmed
Rednihist - super lucky and I could be swayed to believe he is scum, I am simply more sure of the following 3

Scum:
GR - panicky, suddenly, he (along with Rcw) try to start a wagon on scumbag, out of seemingly nowhere
Rcw - super panicky, and remarkably aggressive suddenly, pretty sure he is bussing scumbag...or trying to
Scumbag - his post about the Nicol Bolas realm and that bit at the beginning of day 2

[RedNihilist]

<- be back on monday

[rcwraspy]

McDonalds, you think I've been panicky recently (which I haven't been, and I'm not sure how you can read it as such) and aggressive suddenly, therefore I'm scum? How about the rest of the game? Or are all your conclusions just based on the last page or two?

And my vote on Khadaffi (which I've taken off in deference to the rez/manders thing) isn't "seemingly out of nowhere." A confirmed townie came back from the dead and advised us to do that, which I take as a strong hint and I'm not sure why other people are shrugging it off. Couple that with the fact that any heat on Khadaffi has simply been met with different variations of "your vote is bad and you should feel bad" from him and that's where I'll continue to vote for now.

[Col. Khaddafi]

Oh yeah rcwrspy, I'm sorry for reacting poorly for when imopen2 voted me because I made one comment about the night kill he didn't like and then everybody hopped on the train, how foolish of me to disparrage such advanced scumhunting techniques.

Nevermind that I have been making actual efforts at scumhunting for all the game while you and your buddies have been comfortably lurking for most of the game. I should take a cue from you guys and actually lurk more, this has proven to be the road to a quick town win in this game

[Col. Khaddafi]

Also @McDonalds: what about my post about Bolas Realm? what about it is scummy?

Anyway I'm rereading the game, should come up with my conclusions later on.

[hamfactorial]

Can we get some more planeswalking? Another visit to Serra's Realm, Orzhova or Innistrad would be great.

[rezombad]

Use your plane ability beeyotch

[rezombad]

Also we don't need to go to innistrad

[hamfactorial]

I already did, I brought us here

[hamfactorial]

Ah, you're right about Innistrad.

[Col. Khaddafi]

For reference here is a list of all the day end votes. I'll be adding a list of all the other votecounts later on

That's a lynch!

Jamie (7): Col. Khaddafi, TubeHunter, ( G_R ), hamfactorial, rcwraspy, Manders, Mcdonalds
rcwraspy (2): rezombad
rianalnn (1): WitchHunt
TubeHunter (2): imopen2, Jamie
Manders (1): rianalnn

Not voting: RedNihilist

Final Votecount

Col. Khaddafi (2): rianalnn, RedNihilist
RedNihilist (1): imopen2
rezombad (3): ( G_R ), PedroBear, rcwraspy
( G_R ) (4): rezombad, Col. Khaddafi, hamfactorial, Mcdonalds

Not voting: WitchHunt

You are currently on Serra's Realm.

That's a lynch!

Col. Khaddafi (1): rcwraspy
imopen2 (6): Mcdonalds, hamfactorial, rezombad, Pedrobear, Col. Khaddafi, RedNihilist
Mcdonalds (1): WitchHunt
Pedrobear (1): ( G_R )

Not voting: imopen2

[Col. Khaddafi]

And these are the lynches that didn't go through

Votecount

Col. Khaddafi (4): imopen2, rianalnn, Mcdonalds, RedNihilist
WitchHunt (1): ( G_R )

Not voting: hamfactorial, rezombad, rcwraspy, Col. Khaddafi, WitchHunt, TubeHunter

With 11 alive, it's 6 to lynch.

You are currently on Innistrad.

Votecount

Col. Khaddafi (4): imopen2, rianalnn, Mcdonalds, RedNihilist
WitchHunt (1): ( G_R )
RedNihilist (1): rezombad

Not voting: hamfactorial, rcwraspy, Col. Khaddafi, WitchHunt, PedroBear

With 11 alive, it's 6 to lynch.


Deadline extended to one week + 4 hours from the time of this post, 12:00 noon MST, Tuesday May 26. Deadline Clock.

You are currently on Mercadia.

Votecount

Col. Khaddafi (3): rianalnn, Mcdonalds, RedNihilist
RedNihilist (1): imopen2
rezombad (4): ( G_R ), hamfactorial, PedroBear, rcwraspy
( G_R ) (2): rezombad, Col. Khaddafi

Not voting: WitchHunt

With 11 alive plus the effect of Mercadia, it's 7 to lynch.


Deadline in just under 5 hours. Deadline Clock.

[Col. Khaddafi]

So, looking at the day ends, there is someone who stands out the scummiest, which is McDonalds.

- He hammered Jamie Day 1.
- He was the last to vote GR before the day ended

He was the first to vote imopen2 though.

For the wagons that did not follow through (Col. Lhaddafi and rezombad), its McDonalds and RedNihilist as the last voters and rcwraspy as the last on rez (not counting Pedrobear who is confirmed town).

[rezombad]

Ah, you're right about Innistrad.

No dumbass, use the ability the plane has given you on me

[hamfactorial]

Ah, you're right about Innistrad.

No dumbass, use the ability the plane has given you on me

I submitted my choice to Stardust yesterday.

[rezombad]

K.
planeswalk

[Stardust]

You are now on Ravnica, at Orzhova. While at Orzhova, dead players may post at any time in either the game thread or factional quicktopics, but cannot vote or use any other abilities.

[rezombad]

Neat

[Col. Khaddafi]

Lets get this party started

[( G_R )]

Alright, no private walking now. I do believe the extra walk was a one shot thing, so we should be safe now...

[hamfactorial]

I hope you're right. Why do you believe it was a 1-shot deal?

[WitchHunt]

There's no reason to believe it was a one shot unless it was yours. I could use my secondary walk once per day.

[Manders]

Thank fuck!!

You guys, seriously? I actually did say what rez said I did. Slow down and analyze. TownScum lists should be pouring in right now, and they're not.

The one TS list posted was awful. If he's actually Town, he needs to up his game a lot.

My top pics for scum are Red McDonals Wraspy. The reasons are out there. REREAD.

I'll try to post more in depth while I can.

[Manders]

Planeswalk

You are now on Serra's Realm. When you planeswalk here, if the player who planeswalked is town, that player has a 50% chance of being publically confirmed town.

The angels sing as Pedrobear is haloed by holy light! Pedrobear is confirmed town.

I missed this. Awesome.

[hamfactorial]

Thanks Manders, ya da bess

[Manders]

Ham and Scumbag have already walked this Day, so whenever the private walk boots us from here, it wasn't them. Too bad you guys were more concerned with voting than walking.

Sheesh.

Hammy go to Bromance chat, bro.