[Basic Mafia Game #1] Adventure Time (Town Win)

[Manders]

Hi, Seppel.

[( G_R )]

He confirmed in yet?

[Manders]

He confirmed in yet?

We need someone, and he's willing, so I don't see why not.

[( G_R )]

I'm all for it, but he needs his PM and that in order to start participating... and that's what we need, his participation.

[Shalako]

Happening Now. EDIT: Has Happened now; Waiting to see if Teefo is going to replace back in. EditEdit: Die Store Removal is replacing Jones

[Ximbad]

[Die Store Moval]

Ugh, not even two pages in and it's already time for the shitty player or scum game. Posts like "oh boy" and "srs bzns" are just the worst. Unless you have a posting restriction that demands you post drivel let's try to be productive. Scum doesn't catch itself.

fos: CM & Yanni

FoS but no vote on Yanni.

The notion of RVS is moronic. It makes the thread longer and it's not like those posts won't be reviewed in later days. Every posts in a game of mafia matters. You say you spam because "lolrvs", but you don't get to tell us your motives. I've said my
piece, I thoroughly believe that you're wrong, and I ESPECIALLY think it's scummy to defend posting drivel. If you don't have some reads by page two you're playing a different game than I am, and your game sounds worse.

Thus far things of interest:

Yanni's initial rhyming post, accompanying a vote- Important to note, though possibly nothing. Any comments, Yanni?
Mogadishu jones' vote everyone- A bit out of character for him, but I don't generally try to game the player. In my mind this is akin to gaming the mod. I haven't exactly read a lot of his games either.

Seems rather early to be voting for people but what do i know?

Vote: Captain Murphy

amidoingthisrite?

"is this what townies do? Can I be town"- not very natural. fos: imopen2. Another bad or scum dilemma.

Manders asking for a soft-claim and then asking about what to soft claim, as has been stated, is very suspicious. The inquiry as to what to soft
claim sounds like she's trying to get another player to reveal something, however I don't see what relevant information she could acquire. We'll see how this one plays out.

Still no word from killjoy or teef.

It occurs to me that Ximbad is the only player in the game that I would expect to know what he's doing while basically posting nothing. I would like to know more about everything I commented on, but what Ximbad didn't say feels the most relevant to me.

unvote: the guardian
vote: ximbad

I'm trying to wrap my head around this post. Phantom calls out imopen2 for something I would've voted him for (naked voted + amidoingitright). He even calla out Manders about asking for a soft claim, which, from what I can tell, is pointless, but not malicious. But then after all that, he places his vote on a lurker. What is up?

So you fos me but you think ximbad and yanni are the scum?

Interesting post. Only members of the mafia know to a certainty how many of them there are. I would assume 2-3, but I have no reason to believe one number over the other. You're absolutely a suspicious character thus far and this post helps you none. It's also laughable that your claim against me is that I don't definitively believe you to be scum. As per your request you're officially ahead of Ximbad on the list.

No, impoen pretty much has this right.

Like, seriously, you guys actually thought I had a NEFARIOUS PLOT in mind behind asking about a soft claim?

GTFOOH.
(Get The Fuck Out Of Here for anyone who doesn't know.)

EXPLOSIVE MANDERS

Usually a good sign.

Why, Manders, do you want a soft-claim? And after suggesting it, why not go specific with what your idea of a soft claim might be?

Because I'm just stimulating discussion?

I know nothing of Adventure Time.

Seems like a dumb way to stimulate discussion and just points a massive glowing neon sign at you.

If you have no idea about adventure time then a
soft claim would be completely pointless, so why do it? I don't understand your reasoning.

I don't like the idea of soft claiming or any claiming at all this early in the game for no reason, kind of feel like it is a bit disrespectful to the game mod.

Though this post by Teefo makes sense.

...yanni being dead confirmed scum is like the least useful dead confirmed scum ever.

I don't think that being aggressive is scummy, especially on day 1. On the contrary, I assume mafia will try to start the game with a low profile. Sure, experienced players may tap on that, but in that case I will say it's a null tell.

On the other hand, that "tag-team" accusation, to call it that, is making my "spider-sense" tingle.

Vote: imopen2

I don't like the vote, but I'm
getting annoyed at the low amount of useful content in the first three pages, so I peeked ahead and saw that you're an uncc'd doc.

Also holy crap this game day has been going on for an eternity.

Take out GR since he's doc.

Guardian and Manders are fighting too much to be mafia with each other.

Peeked back and found another page of Manders posting throughout the entire page. Saw that PhantomS claimed vig, Toughguy is unlikely since it wasn't fired on N1 and this is a freaking basic.

Guardian / Ximbad
Manders / Ximbad
Phantoms / Guardian
Phantoms / Manders
Phantoms / Ximbad

If Phantoms is town, then Ximbad is pretty much obvious maf and you guys can resolve Guardian vs. Manders the next day.

If Phantoms is mafia, then fuck me I still have to reread.

I really need to be doing work.

[Manders]

Can you claim, please?

[Die Store Moval]

I thought everyone already had. I'm Nilla, bro.

[Manders]

Ok, but who are you? You know how to full-claim, bro.

[Shalako]

PhantomS is being replaced by Teefo.

[Die Store Moval]

Finn the Huuu-man. And great, looks like I'm not going to get answers from PhantomS.

What is everyone's thoughts on the toughguy?

[Manders]

It's pretty unlikely that it's a toughman for a number of reasons, most predominately the one you already commented on (not using it N1).

I was roleblocked N2 and N3, but I'm nilla, so it was a waste of time.

I refused to claim prior to being brought to L-2 because, duh, scum were wasting their time roleblocking me and I wanted them to keep doing so.

Last two scum, if you are town (which I had a gut feeling Jones was, so...) is Ximbad and The Guardian.

[Die Store Moval]

Votecount, plz.

Pending where the votes are, I have a question for you.

[Shalako]

VoteCount!
Manders (1)- The Guardian
The Guardian (1)-Manders
Not Voting: GR, Ximbad, Teefo, Die Store Removal.
With 6 Alive it is 4 to Lynch.

[Die Store Moval]

Okay Manders, if what you say is true, why are you voting Guardian and not Ximbad?

[Manders]

Because the only reason Ximbad is in the last two for scum is because of PoE.

Now why did you ask me that?

[Die Store Moval]

It seems really odd that you're pushing for Guardian's lynch and saying absolutely nothing (that I've seen) about Ximbad, when, even with your PoE, it's either Ximbad and you, or Ximbad and Guardian.

In other words, your decision to vote Guardian over Ximbad makes no sense.

[Manders]

It seems really odd that you're pushing for Guardian's lynch and saying absolutely nothing (that I've seen) about Ximbad, when, even with your PoE, it's either Ximbad and you, or Ximbad and Guardian.

In other words, your decision to vote Guardian over Ximbad makes no sense.

One more thing I need to know before I proceed.

How much of this thread have you read?

[The Dark Guardian]

Quick Question:

Is Dies to Removal Seppel?

[Manders]

No.

Die Store Moval is.

[Die Store Moval]

It seems really odd that you're pushing for Guardian's lynch and saying absolutely nothing (that I've seen) about Ximbad, when, even with your PoE, it's either Ximbad and you, or Ximbad and Guardian.

In other words, your decision to vote Guardian over Ximbad makes no sense.

One more thing I need to know before I proceed.

How much of this thread have you read?

Pages 1 - 3 and pages 18 - 21.

I don't have the time to fully commit to the game, but I still want to know what's up with your vote.

[Manders]

It seems really odd that you're pushing for Guardian's lynch and saying absolutely nothing (that I've seen) about Ximbad, when, even with your PoE, it's either Ximbad and you, or Ximbad and Guardian.

In other words, your decision to vote Guardian over Ximbad makes no sense.

One more thing I need to know before I proceed.

How much of this thread have you read?

Pages 1 - 3 and
pages 18 - 21.

I don't have the time to fully commit to the game, but I still want to know what's up with your vote.

Okay then.

Based on looking back and seeing what occurred on page 18 and later, my vote makes perfect sense.

What doesn't make sense is why you think it doesn't, so why don't you elaborate for me, hmm?

[Die Store Moval]

That's not an answer.

All I want is an answer, regardless of whether it's already in the thread or not. You know I don't have much time to commit, yet you're purposefully making me have to go and re-read.

Page 18 was where you were spamming (mostly) Guardian quotes. From what I've seen, you've said almost nothing about Ximbad. On top of that, the only dichotomy is between you and Guardian.

Nobody's posting, not even the replacement.

Ximbad/Manders, final answer. I'm out.

Vote Ximbad

[( G_R )]

I didn't want to post, because that meant more posts for you to read.

So, we are lynching Ximbad by elimination?

[Manders]

That's not an answer.

All I want is an answer, regardless of whether it's already in the thread or not. You know I don't have much time to commit, yet you're purposefully making me have to go and re-read.

Page 18 was where you were spamming (mostly) Guardian quotes. From what I've seen, you've said almost nothing about Ximbad. On top of that, the only dichotomy is between you and Guardian.

Nobody's posting, not even the replacement.

Ximbad/Manders, final answer. I'm out.

Vote Ximbad

I'm not making you do a goddamn thing.

You said you read it, and you just showed you did.

I already told you that the ONLY thing I have on Ximbad is PoE, and that is based on me thinking YOU are town.

nTherefore, why the fuck would I vote Ximbad over The Guardian, who I showed evidence to support a theory of being scum?

Answer me that, and maybe I'll continue thinking you're town.

As of now, I'm not so sure about Ximbad.

Also, if you've decided it's me and Ximbad, why did you vote him? Why not vote me? You know, SINCE I ALREADY HAVE A VOTE ON ME AND THIS GAME/DAY HAS GONE ON FUCKING FOREVER AND PUTTING A VOTE ON HIM IS JUST RETARDED AS FUCK.

Can you tell me that, hon?

[The Dark Guardian]

That's not an answer.

All I want is an answer, regardless of whether it's already in the thread or not. You know I don't have much time to commit, yet you're purposefully making me have to go and re-read.

Page 18 was where you were spamming (mostly) Guardian quotes. From what I've seen, you've said almost nothing about Ximbad. On top of that, the only dichotomy is between you and Guardian.

Nobody's posting, not even the replacement.

Ximbad/Manders, final answer. I'm out.

Vote Ximbad

I'm not making you do a goddamn thing.

You said you read
it, and you just showed you did.

I already told you that the ONLY thing I have on Ximbad is PoE, and that is based on me thinking YOU are town.

Therefore, why the fuck would I vote Ximbad over The Guardian, who I showed evidence to support a theory of being scum?

Answer me that, and maybe I'll continue thinking you're town.

As of now, I'm not so sure about Ximbad.

Also, if you've decided it's me and Ximbad, why did you vote him? Why not vote me? You know, SINCE I ALREADY HAVE A VOTE ON ME AND THIS GAME/DAY HAS GONE ON FUCKING FOREVER AND PUTTING A VOTE ON HIM IS JUST RETARDED AS FUCK.

Can you tell me that, hon?

I believe you words implied here said that you cemented Ximbad as my scum buddy, unless Jones was REALLY pulling one over on you. What would make you change tomorrow from Xim to Jones/Dies that hasn't been said already?

That said, would like to here G_R and Teefo's opinion first, but I am fine going either Ximbad or Manders.

[( G_R )]

I don't know about lynching Ximbad yet. I just don't see a solid case for that. I don't like the whole I don't claim thing from Manders, because as much as she claims to be misleading Mafia, the town was also being misled. I just don't know how a vanilla gets info about being targeted, specially in a basic, but you guys have more experience than me. In other words, I don't fully trust Manders and would support that lynch. Now that DSM is providing some more content, I can at least put something else on my spreadsheet other than "counterclaimed ( N_S )".

Let's hear from teefo, then.

[The Dark Guardian]

I don't know about lynching Ximbad yet. I just don't see a solid case for that. I don't like the whole I don't claim thing from Manders, because as much as she claims to be misleading Mafia, the town was also being misled. I just don't know how a vanilla gets info about being targeted, specially in a basic, but you guys have more experience than me. In other words, I don't fully trust Manders and would support that lynch. Now that DSM is providing some more content, I can at least put something else on my spreadsheet other than "counterclaimed ( N_S )".

Let's hear from teefo, then.

It's the principle of POA (Process of Elimination).

Because I know I am town, and because I know you and Teefo are town based on alignment, I have two
scum to pick out of the three remaining players (Dies, Manders, and Ximbad). In addition to my own mod gaming theory, the interaction I have seen would not make sense of a Manders/Dies scum team (based on Jones's behavior in game).

The only two remaining combinations are Manders/Ximbad, or Ximbad/Dies. Which is why both myself and Dies want ximbad lynched (his combination elimination is Guardian/Manders).

Also, I could point to his balking/fence sitting/ and blantant uncaring for tomorrow and make a case if I really had to. It just seems like a waste of time...

[( G_R )]

Sure, but in my case I have an additional variable, because I know that I'm town, and that ( G_R ) is town, but I'm ( G_R ), so I have a lot more possible combinations...

[Shalako]

Still waiting on Teefo, sorry.

Here is a distraction

[Shalako]

I'd be doing Deadline/replacements but my GP is in the Hosp. right now and I have to go deal with it.

[The Dark Guardian]

Don't worry about it man. Teefo is probably still trying to catch up.

[Manders]

Xander? o.O

Ok this is officially ridiculous.

Everyone needs to either confirm their vote or vote for who they want to lynch now.

The game is dying. Win or lose, town, it's time to end it.

[( G_R )]

Vote Manders

[Shalako]

It
s the dady after bitrthday. Pretty durnlk.\

ISO IS REPLACING TEFFO REPLACING PHANTOM as of when i send the PM{s; don't modgame fatheads} to him ASAP

Let's get this game moving again, I'll deadline if needed but a bump in activty will prevent that.

POST, MY KINGDOM FOR POSTS

I would like to remind you that IF there is a PM error it is LIKLY my fault.

[Iso]

hay guise

I shot Captain Murphy, apparently. /shrug

I'll need some time to catch up. In the meantime, try not to lynch somebody or impose a deadline, plox.

[Iso]

So, I had a massive wall of G_R quotes up for analysis, and then he claimed Doc. What a waste of time. I also had quotes from Ximbad, Guardian, and Yanni, but I had more GR quotes than anything else so I didn't feel like parsing through a wall of text and deleting all of those.

That said, Yanni pointed out Ximbad's RVS post without actually pushing Ximbad and Ximbad was pushing other wagons seemingly without reason while the Yanni wagon was at its peak on Day 1. I think we can lynch Ximbad toDay and see what comes on the next Day. If GR is scum, he will be alive. I'm the Vig, so if GR is the Doc, I will be alive. I felt good about Mokpaca Jones from early on, so I'm willing to call Seps town. That leaves it between Manders and Guardian, and I liked Manders's accidental hammer of Yanni. So that makes this pretty cut and dry for me.

Vote Ximbad

Let's get this over with.

[( G_R )]

Okay then.

Unvote. Vote Ximbad.

This game has to end already, either way.

[Manders]

Iso, if you've narrowed it down to Guardian or Ximbad, vote Guardian with me. I'm more sure on him and not so sure on Jones/Seps.

And thank you soooooooooo much for replacing in!