[Basic Mafia Game #1] Adventure Time (Town Win)

[Mogadishu Jones]

And I selectively hate emoticons.

[Captain Murphy]

Waaaaahhhhhhh

[Captain Murphy]

I like short posting in mafia, keeps people on their heels and people actually read everything I say

[Manders]

Emoticons love you, kpaca.

[Mogadishu Jones]

I like short posting in mafia, keeps people on their heels and people actually read everything I say

Theres a difference between short posting amd short, useless posting.

[Mogadishu Jones]

Emoticons love you, kpaca.

This for instance

[The Dark Guardian]

Hmm,

This community might be on to something about no RVS. Curious to see how the initiation process will play on in future games, but for this game:

Why, Manders, do you want a soft-claim? And after suggesting it, why not go specific with what your idea of a soft claim might be?

[Col. Khaddafi]

One thing that I asked in my last mod lounge game and no one answered is what you are supposed to do on day one, before people even voted for someone's lynch. For my first game it just felt like a free for all.

[Yannaria]

I don't want to soft claim without manders explaining more.

[Yannaria]

As with all games, mafia can easily be ruined by people just not caring about the game. It is very bad for the town to have spammy townies, because spamming is outright scummy. I don't understand why some people just don't get that. As a member of the town, you contribute. You have nothing to hide, therefor you talk words like a real person.

while I agree with you when the game gets rolling, dude, rvs.

[imopen2]

I don't want to soft anything till I know what a "claim" is..

Also, rvs? ?_?

Time to go read the rules again...

[imopen2]

Ok, I've read the rules again.

I would say: tell me more about the conditions of this soft-claim, manders. I thought we couldn't reveal any part of our role pm.

Rvs: seems like we're already doing this, eh? It doesn't seem like banning chatter is very important right now

[imopen2]

And now I've reread page 1 and realize you just can't quote your pm. Gotcha

[The Dark Guardian]

Unvote Yanni

A soft-claim is essentially a claim that tries to hint at the name of each players role (common ones include gender claims).

My problem right now is that even without the knowledge of AT, there are still many claims one could make. Gender claim, human claim (lols), princess claim. Whether soft-claiming is viable now or not is beyond me, but why not specify something to the rest of the players?

[Yannaria]

Unvote Yanni

A soft-claim is essentially a claim that tries to hint at the name of each players role (common ones include gender claims).

My problem right now is that even without the knowledge of AT, there are still many claims one could make. Gender claim, human claim (lols), princess claim. Whether soft-claiming is viable now or not is beyond me, but why not specify something to the rest of the players?

this is basically my problem.
I've seen maybe two episodes of AT and I absolutely hate the idea of trying to flavor break the game.

[Mogadishu Jones]

As with all games, mafia can easily be ruined by people just not caring about the game. It is very bad for the town to have spammy townies, because spamming is outright scummy. I don't understand why some people just don't get that. As a member of the town, you contribute. You have nothing to hide, therefor you talk words like a real person.

while I agree with you when the game gets rolling, dude, rvs.

Still really worried about defending your inane drivel.

[Mogadishu Jones]

Unvote Yanni

A soft-claim is essentially a claim that tries to hint at the name of each players role (common ones include gender claims).

My problem right now is that even without the knowledge of AT, there are still many claims one could make. Gender claim, human claim (lols), princess claim. Whether soft-claiming is viable now or not is beyond me, but why not specify something to the rest of the players?

Well fucking vote her already, or are you just going to talk about how much you dont like what manders did?

[Mogadishu Jones]

One thing that I asked in my last mod lounge game and no one answered is what you are supposed to do on day one, before people even voted for someone's lynch. For my first game it just felt like a free for all.

Hope for the best.

[PhantomS]

The notion of RVS is moronic. It makes the thread longer and it's not like those posts won't be reviewed in later days. Every posts in a game of mafia matters. You say you spam because "lolrvs", but you don't get to tell us your motives. I've said my piece, I thoroughly believe that you're wrong, and I ESPECIALLY think it's scummy to defend posting drivel. If you don't have some reads by page two you're playing a different game than I am, and your game sounds worse.

Thus far things of interest:

Yanni's initial rhyming post, accompanying a vote- Important to note, though possibly nothing. Any comments, Yanni?
Mogadishu jones' vote everyone- A bit out of character for him, but I don't generally try to game the player. In my mind this is akin to gaming the mod. I haven't exactly read a lot of his games either.

Seems rather early to be voting for people but what
do i know?

Vote: Captain Murphy

amidoingthisrite?

"is this what townies do? Can I be town"- not very natural. fos: imopen2. Another bad or scum dilemma.

Manders asking for a soft-claim and then asking about what to soft claim, as has been stated, is very suspicious. The inquiry as to what to soft claim sounds like she's trying to get another player to reveal something, however I don't see what relevant information she could acquire. We'll see how this one plays out.

Still no word from killjoy or teef.

It occurs to me that Ximbad is the only player in the game that I would expect to know what he's doing while basically posting nothing. I would like to know more about everything I commented on, but what Ximbad didn't say feels the most relevant to me.

unvote: the guardian
vote: ximbad

[PhantomS]

Meant captain murphy's rhyming post, not yannis. Also, in case it wasn't clear yanni is not too far behind ximbad on my list of shady characters.

[Yannaria]

The notion of RVS is moronic. It makes the thread longer and it's not like those posts won't be reviewed in later days. Every posts in a game of mafia matters. You say you spam because "lolrvs", but you don't get to tell us your motives. I've said my piece, I thoroughly believe that you're wrong, and I ESPECIALLY think it's scummy to defend posting drivel. If you don't have some reads by page two you're playing a different game than I am, and your game sounds worse.

Of course I have reads, when did I say I didn't

RVS posts, for the most part, are useful in 3 sceanarios, 1. when we have dead scum and we can look at interactions from that person 2. when a town member is dead and we can look at interactions from that person.
3. how people react to RVS posts and
how it paints them in a scum/town light.

I think that you're grasping at straws when attacking me for doing something that is pretty common in almost all mafia games.

[imopen2]

The notion of RVS is moronic. It makes the thread longer and it's not like those posts won't be reviewed in later days. Every posts in a game of mafia matters. You say you spam because "lolrvs", but you don't get to tell us your motives. I've said my piece, I thoroughly believe that you're wrong, and I ESPECIALLY think it's scummy to defend posting drivel. If you don't have some reads by page two you're playing a different game than I am, and your game sounds worse.

Thus far things of interest:

Yanni's initial rhyming post, accompanying a vote- Important to note, though possibly nothing. Any comments, Yanni?
Mogadishu jones' vote everyone- A bit out of character for him, but I don't generally try to game the player. In my mind
this is akin to gaming the mod. I haven't exactly read a lot of his games either.

Seems rather early to be voting for people but what do i know?

Vote: Captain Murphy

amidoingthisrite?

"is this what townies do? Can I be town"- not very natural. fos: imopen2. Another bad or scum dilemma.

Manders asking for a soft-claim and then asking about what to soft claim, as has been stated, is very suspicious. The inquiry as to what to soft claim sounds like she's trying to get another player to reveal something, however I don't see what relevant information she could acquire. We'll see how this one plays out.

Still no word from killjoy or teef.

It occurs to me that Ximbad is the only player in the game that I would expect to know what he's doing while basically posting nothing. I would like to know more about everything I commented on, but what Ximbad didn't say feels the most relevant to me.

unvote: the
guardian
vote: ximbad

So you fos me but you think ximbad and yanni are the scum?

[Mogadishu Jones]

The notion of RVS is moronic. It makes the thread longer and it's not like those posts won't be reviewed in later days. Every posts in a game of mafia matters. You say you spam because "lolrvs", but you don't get to tell us your motives. I've said my piece, I thoroughly believe that you're wrong, and I ESPECIALLY think it's scummy to defend posting drivel. If you don't have some reads by page two you're playing a different game than I am, and your game sounds worse.

Of course I have reads, when did I say I didn't

RVS posts, for the most part, are useful in 3 sceanarios, 1. when we have dead scum and
we can look at interactions from that person 2. when a town member is dead and we can look at interactions from that person.
3. how people react to RVS posts and how it paints them in a scum/town light.

I think that you're grasping at straws when attacking me for doing something that is pretty common in almost all mafia games.

Rvs posts are pretty useless except when we catch people like you trying to steadfastly defend it. unvote: vote yanni

[PhantomS]

The notion of RVS is moronic. It makes the thread longer and it's not like those posts won't be reviewed in later days. Every posts in a game of mafia matters. You say you spam because "lolrvs", but you don't get to tell us your motives. I've said my piece, I thoroughly believe that you're wrong, and I ESPECIALLY think it's scummy to defend posting drivel. If you don't have some reads by page two you're playing a different game than I am, and your game sounds worse.

Of course I have reads, when did I say I didn't

RVS posts, for the most part, are useful in 3 sceanarios, 1. when we have dead scum
and we can look at interactions from that person 2. when a town member is dead and we can look at interactions from that person.
3. how people react to RVS posts and how it paints them in a scum/town light.

I think that you're grasping at straws when attacking me for doing something that is pretty common in almost all mafia games.

You have reads and still refuse to generate constructive comments. Your job is to convince me that you're the worst town ever, or I will maintain that you're scum.

unvote: ximbad
vote: yanni

[PhantomS]

So you fos me but you think ximbad and yanni are the scum?

Interesting post. Only members of the mafia know to a certainty how many of them there are. I would assume 2-3, but I have no reason to believe one number over the other. You're absolutely a suspicious character thus far and this post helps you none. It's also laughable that your claim against me is that I don't definitively believe you to be scum. As per your request you're officially ahead of Ximbad on the list.

[teefo]

sry guys i was doing new years parties i have read shit and will post when i'm not super hung over peace out

[teefo]

though with just a glossy read kp and phanty seem to have some sort of agenda maybe idk they are friends but they are being a bit too friendly but what do i know i have only slept for 2 hours

[teefo]

though yanni is obv obv playing like a dork i think he is just dumb rather than scummy but again i will re read

[imopen2]

So you fos me but you think ximbad and yanni are the scum?

Interesting post. Only members of the mafia know to a certainty how many of them there are. I would assume 2-3, but I have no reason to believe one number over the other. You're absolutely a suspicious character thus far and this post helps you none. It's also laughable that your claim against me is that I don't definitively believe you to be scum. As per your request you're officially ahead of Ximbad on the list.

dokay

[Yannaria]

The notion of RVS is moronic. It makes the thread longer and it's not like those posts won't be reviewed in later days. Every posts in a game of mafia matters. You say you spam because "lolrvs", but you don't get to tell us your motives. I've said my piece, I thoroughly believe that you're wrong, and I ESPECIALLY think it's scummy to defend posting drivel. If you don't have some reads by page two you're playing a different game than I am, and your game sounds worse.

Of course I have reads, when did I say I didn't

RVS posts, for the most part, are useful in 3 sceanarios, 1. when we have dead scum and we can look at interactions from that person 2. when a town member is dead and we can look at interactions from that person.
3. how people react to RVS posts and how it paints them in a scum/town light.

I think that you're grasping at straws when attacking me for doing something that is pretty common in almost all mafia games.

You have reads and still refuse to generate constructive comments. Your job is to convince me that you're the worst town ever, or I will maintain that you're scum.

unvote: ximbad
vote: yanni

lol fun times. I'm not exposing my reads until Manders comes in and explains why she wants to softclaim.

Rvs posts are pretty useless except when we catch people like you trying to steadfastly defend it.
unvote: vote yanni

how am I steadfastly defending my RVS posts as opposed to defending the practice of RVS in mafia entirely?

[Mogadishu Jones]

Lol how is that even a question?

Answer: through text

[Manders]

Why, Manders, do you want a soft-claim? And after suggesting it, why not go specific with what your idea of a soft claim might be?

Because I'm just stimulating discussion?

I know nothing of Adventure Time.

[Manders]

Like, seriously, you guys actually thought I had a NEFARIOUS PLOT in mind behind asking about a soft claim?

GTFOOH. (Get The Fuck Out Of Here for anyone who doesn't know.)

[Yannaria]

Lol how is that even a question?

Answer: through text

lol yeah because we were having a discussion about RVS or at least I was, not my posts specifically

[PhantomS]

How could we have a discussion about RVS without calling your posts into question?

"I was talking about math, that has nothing to do with the number 7!"

[Manders]

Yanni, if my answer was so important that you made it a point to mention it in a previous post, why did you just ignore that you'd obtained it?

[Killjoy]

I'll read up tonight. New years was fun.

[Captain Murphy]

[quote="[url=viewtopic.php?p=22175#p22175:33id95sk]PhantomS » Tue Jan 01, 2013 5:12 am[/url:33id95sk]":33id95sk]Meant captain murphy's rhyming post, not yannis. Also, in case it wasn't clear yanni is not too far behind ximbad on my list of shady characters.[/quote:33id95sk]
I make my RVS posts relevant and I wanted the first post of the game to be a quick rhyme

But I do love the one guy in every game who makes an uproar about RVS and votes people for caring about RVS while not realizing that saying you don't care about RVS and voting for someone is practically caring about RVS because your whole argument is "R-V-S"

Yanni posts like a tard when he is town and aggressively as mafia so he is not worth your time phantom. I do find the string of imopen2 posts though...

[b:33id95sk]unvote[/b:33id95sk]

[teefo]

Why, Manders, do you want a soft-claim? And after suggesting it, why not go specific with what your idea of a soft claim might be?

Because I'm just stimulating discussion?

I know nothing of Adventure Time.

Seems like a dumb way to stimulate discussion and just points a massive glowing neon sign at you.

If you have no idea about adventure time then a soft claim would be completely pointless, so why do it? I don't understand your reasoning.

I don't like the idea of soft claiming or any claiming at all this early in the game for no reason, kind
of feel like it is a bit disrespectful to the game mod.

[teefo]

someone do a vote count for me i am lazy