Was there any way I could have avoided being lynched on day 1? I felt like Tube killing Z sealed my fate and splashed too much doubt on me. Being true vanilla town made it even worse when it came time for claims.
You should have responded to my gambit. I was already on my way to reading you as town, but I needed you to give me something, and you opted not to. You should try to be more active in actually finding and killing scum (easy to say, I know).
Also, you weren't vanilla. The fact that you kept repeating that kind of drove me crazy and made me think you must be hiding other abilities.
[quote="
rezombad » Fri Dec 06, 2013 3:22 pm":
1ng87mcx]
let it all out
and please, interpreting what I think about what you think is a fucking stupid strike against me, and you know it.
The vig didn't bother me that much, personally. The only reason I though you were scummy was because pie was buddying you so fucking hard.[/quote]
Scummers buddy townies all the time. If it's blatant, it's probably not scum on scum.
So the 2 most obvious things I could have done better:
1. Vanilla Town claim. In a game like this, I needed to come up with SOMETHING.
2. If I was pushing Tube as scum so hard, I should have had Pie as the no-questions #2 scum in my mind due to his buddying Tube - instead of a "
weak read"
Anything else?
Day 1 you played really well. Once you caught my attention with the vanilla claim, I read back a couple pages and then noticed that you failed to take many strong stances. That'll fly in the early game, but as the game developed it became pretty clear that you weren't reading people at all (ie: that your reads were fake).
