[Fedoras of Salvation] - White Knights ITT

[Alex]

Why didn't you guys tell me that Reddit was the exact same thing as MTGS in terms of poster quality?

[Link]

oh my god battledriver into hydra is fuckign disgusting and happens more than I thought


Kincey you are a genius

now about that $30 price tag T_T

It is possible it wants mystics and more hydras (obviously so after rotation and losnig hellkite)

I was testing against Esper control too for maximum disruption... between Domri and BTE they def can't keep up with the smash

[rcwraspy]

LP, I think you like that Dega Midrange list, right? I think you've posted about it a few times. Maybe I'm getting you confused with someone else. Hopefully we're not stepping on your toes in that thread.

If you are the one I'm thinking of and like the archetype, any desire to post a primer over here?

[Valdarith]

LP, I think you like that Dega Midrange list, right? I think you've posted about it a few times. Maybe I'm getting you confused with someone else. Hopefully we're not stepping on your toes in that thread.

If you are the one I'm thinking of and like the archetype, any desire to post a primer over here?

Pretty sure it's LP you're thinking of but I also think the archetype fell out of his favor recently.

[Kazekirimaru]

As much as I'd love to contribute to the Dega Midrange cesspool, I can't think of any replies that won't get me modraped.

[Kazekirimaru]

Oh, well. Have fun storming the castle.

[Calamity]

Why didn't you guys tell me that Reddit was the exact same thing as MTGS in terms of poster quality?

Reddit is pretty much the worst site for discussion. The nature of the up/down vote system ensures that only the 'popular' (bad) opinions are heard

[Alex]

As much as I'd love to contribute to the Dega Midrange cesspool, I can't think of any replies that won't get me modraped.

Oh don't worry, we're all going to get red carded despite being well within the guidelines set fourth. You're smart for staying out.

[Khaospawn]

The Dega thread is just pure comedy. I'm making popcorn now for the entertainment.

[windstrider]

This reply makes me want to stab my eyes out with a fork.

"Logical fallacies are only discredited in the process of creating persuasive paper that usually has multiple pages of evidence backing your opinion. In a scene of discussion however, both which is informal and constructive, logical fallacies can be used in a legal manner."
http://forums.mtgsalvation.com/showpost ... count=1729

No, no, fucking, no. Fallacies are errors in reasoning. They are wrong in every context.

[Khaospawn]

Apparently, Kamahl like to name drop that his testing buddy is our very own LP.

[Alex]

Apparently, Kamahl like to name drop that his testing buddy is our very own LP.

Maybe, maybe not. (LK did keep his nose out of this one, which is very unlike him!)

Despite that, it doesn't make any difference. The guy is obviously mentally inept.

[Khaospawn]

I just want to ask him if he even lifts.

[Lightning_Dolt]

I think the real discussion point really should be "Why is Ogre Battledriver only three bucks?"

That card is the literal nuts.

It's a promo card,

For what? I was not aware of this.

and it's not that great?

Incorrect statement is incorrect. It will be our new Hellrider in a few months and it makes AIR a much better
archetype. Also quite good in Sledgehammer builds. (Five drops that were previously only "meh" without Haste? NP.) It's good for basically all of the same reasons that Hero of Oxid Ridge was good.

Duels 2014 on PS3.

[Alex]

I don't think anyone got Duels for anything other than Scavening Ooze. (Which was Steam or iOS or something right?)

[Jack]

Either one. Is the promo worth any money? I remember selling the one from the Commander precon for the price of the deck

[hamfactorial]

This reply makes me want to stab my eyes out with a fork.

"Logical fallacies are only discredited in the process of creating persuasive paper that usually has multiple pages of evidence backing your opinion. In a scene of discussion however, both which is informal and constructive, logical fallacies can be used in a legal manner."
http://forums.mtgsalvation.com/showpost ... count=1729

No, no, fucking, no. Fallacies are errors in reasoning. They are wrong in every context.

I couldn't stop laughing when I read this one, Dan. His argument essentially is "since your reply pointing
out my logical fallacy isn't submitted in essay format to a literary journal, it is therefore invalid, thus there is no fallacy in my argument."

It's some special bastard of a straw man and a moving goalpost.

My head asplode.

[Alex]

Either one. Is the promo worth any money? I remember selling the one from the Commander precon for the price of the deck

On Starcity it says $40 but I wouldn't expect to get that out of it, being reprinted at rare probably just killed the price.

[TubeHunter]

i feel like i missed things...

[windstrider]

I honestly don't know what he meant with that word salad of a response. His contention that logical fallacies are ever "legal", whatever the fuck that means, demonstrates that he has very limited understanding of them.

[hamfactorial]

I just want to ask him if he even lifts.

I saw that he gave you the golden opportunity to ask and you took it.

That's my boy!

[Alex]

Well, there's double mods in the thread now so I expect some red cards within the near future.

[TubeHunter]

i guess the thing is still open to trolll..... to the vexing devil mobile!

[Alex]

And now we have 3 guests in the clan forum. Here we go.

[Khaospawn]

I just want to ask him if he even lifts.

I saw that he gave you the golden opportunity to ask and you took it.

That's my boy!

Daddy ham, did I make you proud?

[Khaospawn]

Well, there's double mods in the thread now so I expect some red cards within the near future.

5-0 creepin'!

[TubeHunter]

were the kids of the future. whoah

[Self Medicated]

I still don't understand how someone can say Purge the Profane is better than Rakdos's Return. When I looked up tournament results for the last 3 months, Purge hasn't put up any results, while Return has been in approximately 150 decks that made top 16 at large tournaments. Why is he even arguing?

[Alex]

Hmm, they left the Dega thread and I am still without an infraction. Curious.

[TubeHunter]

HAVE THEY SEEN THE LIGHT!?

[TubeHunter]

THE FIRE IN THE RHETORICAL DARKNESS?

[TubeHunter]

OF SALVATION?

[Khaospawn]

I kind of get the impression that the mainstream of posters on Sally have the notion that the FoS are some sort of rebel, guerrilla fighters with a sole mission to derail threads started up by people they don't like.


I suppose they wouldn't be far from the truth.

[Alex]

I kind of get the impression that the mainstream of posters on Sally have the notion that the FoS are some sort of rebel, guerrilla fighters with a sole mission to derail threads started up by people they don't like.


I suppose they wouldn't be far from the truth.

The funny thing is, he's still yet to actually respond to anybody, he's still yelling "NU-UH."

It's hysterical because I called it like 2 pages ago.

[TubeHunter]

I kind of get the impression that the mainstream of posters on Sally have the notion that the FoS are some sort of rebel, guerrilla fighters with a sole mission to derail threads started up by people they don't like.


I suppose they wouldn't be far from the truth.

Thats my main function

[windstrider]

I still don't understand how someone can say Purge of the Profane is better than Rakdos's Return. When I looked up tournament results for the last 3 months, Purge hasn't put up any results, while Return has been in approximately 150 decks that made top 16 at large tournaments. Why is he even arguing?

Paraphrased:
Because he used Purge to a strong finish in a top event that's better than all the other FNM events that people were playing in.

Classic hasty generalization.

[Khaospawn]

I kind of get the impression that the mainstream of posters on Sally have the notion that the FoS are some sort of rebel, guerrilla fighters with a sole mission to derail threads started up by people they don't like.


I suppose they wouldn't be far from the truth.

Thats my main function

And that's why we love ya, tubehunter

[Alex]

I still don't understand how someone can say Purge of the Profane is better than Rakdos's Return. When I looked up tournament results for the last 3 months, Purge hasn't put up any results, while Return has been in approximately 150 decks that made top 16 at large tournaments. Why is he even arguing?

Paraphrased:
Because he used Purge to a strong finish in a top event that's better than all the other FNM events that people were playing in.

Classic hasty generalization.

I still liked my example better.

[Khaospawn]

[quote="[url=viewtopic.php?p=80205#p80205:2bhucn1p]Alex » Mon Jul 15, 2013 6:38 pm[/url:2bhucn1p]":2bhucn1p][quote="[url=viewtopic.php?p=80204#p80204:2bhucn1p]Khaospawn » Mon Jul 15, 2013 5:37 pm[/url:2bhucn1p]":2bhucn1p]I kind of get the impression that the mainstream of posters on Sally have the notion that the FoS are some sort of rebel, guerrilla fighters with a sole mission to derail threads started up by people they don't like.


I suppose they wouldn't be far from the truth.[/quote:2bhucn1p]
The funny thing is, he's still yet to actually respond to anybody, he's still yelling "NU-UH."

It's hysterical because I called it like 2 pages ago.[/quote:2bhucn1p]
I wonder if I should ask him how his Mono Red MU is?

Admittedly, I'd be trolling.

[Self Medicated]

I still don't understand how someone can say Purge of the Profane is better than Rakdos's Return. When I looked up tournament results for the last 3 months, Purge hasn't put up any results, while Return has been in approximately 150 decks that made top 16 at large tournaments. Why is he even arguing?

Paraphrased:
Because he used Purge to a strong finish in a top event that's better than all the other FNM events that
people were playing in.

Classic hasty generalization.

I still liked my example better.

I didn't catch your example. Been trying to read through everything at work. Needless to say, I'm not getting much done right now.