Bioshock Mafia (Town Win)

[Captain Murphy]

Cool. Let's do this (hopefully I survive the night)

If I die it will be in glorious respect of my great night one death records

[rezombad]

I'll be pretty satisfied if I die tonight.

[imopen2]

Well D1's over, Scumbag should be happy.

If there is a doctor (one who can actually help people, not like GR PhD thing) you should consider targeting the cop too. Don't tell us, but if WitchHunt gets roleblocked or something, we want the cop to be safe and there needs to be a slight chance that targeting the cop with a NK won't work for scum. GR hope that made sense.

No, the doc is protecting our watcher

I don't have an opinion one way or the other, but I don't think we should be openly directing our doc (if we have one). Seems way too easy for the
scum to strategize around

[( G_R )]

Well D1's over, Scumbag should be happy.

If there is a doctor (one who can actually help people, not like GR PhD thing) you should consider targeting the cop too. Don't tell us, but if WitchHunt gets roleblocked or something, we want the cop to be safe and there needs to be a slight chance that targeting the cop with a NK won't work for scum. GR hope that made sense.

No, the doc is protecting our watcher

I'd like the doc to make that choice, giving us a 50% chance that if the watcher is roleblocked, the cop is still protected.

POST REVIEW
At least
one new post has been made to this topic. You may wish to review your post in light of this.

@imopen2: exactly my point.

[( G_R )]

Damnit, forgot the flavor gaming again.

[Captain Murphy]

They don't who the doc is (even if we have one) and witch's claim is stronger than yours

[Captain Murphy]

Well D1's over, Scumbag should be happy.

If there is a doctor (one who can actually help people, not like GR PhD thing) you should consider targeting the cop too. Don't tell us, but if WitchHunt gets roleblocked or something, we want the cop to be safe and there needs to be a slight chance that targeting the cop with a NK won't work for scum. GR hope that made sense.

No, the doc is protecting our
watcher

I'd like the doc to make that choice, giving us a 50% chance that if the watcher is roleblocked, the cop is still protected.

POST REVIEW
At least one new post has been made to this topic. You may wish to review your post in light of this.

@imopen2: exactly my point.

Why would the scum team role block a watcher when they can role block the cop? Witch has the most potential to die

[imopen2]

They don't who the doc is (even if we have one) and witch's claim is stronger than yours

I agree, but I know my claim is true and don't want to lay out our plans so explicitly. If the doc wants to take your advice I have no problem with it.

[( G_R )]

GR see your point CM. Fair enough.

[Col. Khaddafi]

Yeah just cop me tonight so that Yanni can shut his trap once and for all

[Stardust]

Why would the scum team role block a watcher when they can role block the cop? Witch has the most potential to die

Because knowing that the doc will be targeting the watcher, they can roleblock the watcher and kill the cop. No town results and a dead cop seems decent.

But don't worry. The doc knows what he's doing. Just gotta have faith, faith, faith.

[rezombad]

Why would the scum team role block a watcher when they can role block the cop? Witch has the most potential to die

Because knowing that the doc will be targeting the watcher, they can roleblock the watcher and kill the cop. No town results and a dead cop seems decent.

But don't worry. The doc knows what he's doing. Just gotta have faith, faith, faith.

[Yannaria]

stop all this WIFOM now.

[imopen2]

stop all this WIFOM now.

Agreed. Let's all shut up and wait for night. Unless you think of something important

[Second Harkius]

Lord_McDonalds (7) – Kazekirimaru, Rezombad, Captain Murphy, Stardust, WitchHunt, Yannaria, TubeHunter

"But I'm Anna Culpepper! Most of the songs on the radio are mine! I'm the voice of Rapture!"

Lord_McDonald's pleas are in vain. In a spliced up frenzy, and eager to end the day, his fellow splicers pick him up and carry him into small metal room and quickly slam the bulkhead door. As he begins to hear the bulkhead door on the other side of the room open, he realizes he's about to meet a watery grave. Chuckling to himself - perhaps in resigned despair - McDonald's realizes that his songs will live on far longer than he will. Maybe his songs can help the citizens of Rapture fight off the parasites......

Lord McDonalds was

---

[
color=#0000FF]Anna Culpepper, Pro-Rapture Ghostly Presence Splicer[/color]. As one of Rapture’s most famous singers, your voice is known all over the city. While you were once Andrew Ryan’s biggest critic, you’ve come to realize that Rapture is a paradise compared to the violent surface world. Your protest songs are now flowery ballads praising science, determination, and the indomitable will that all great men share. Your music is so popular that it will surely survive long after your death.

Passive Ability: If you are night killed or lynched, you will still be able to post in the game thread; however, you will no longer be able to vote.

IT IS NOW NIGHT 1. Please do not post in this thread until day 2.

All night actions are due by Sunday, October 27th at 11:59 PM EST. If you do not submit an action by then, your action will not be counted.

[Second Harkius]

Night 1 ends early.

While it seems like a quiet night in Rapture, there's murder afoot. The devious Colonel_Khaddafi has broken into Captain_Murphy's house with malicious intent. Sneaking up on the passed out Murphy, Khaddafi proceeds to bash his brain in with a candlestick. Satisfied that he's turned Murphy's skull to mush, Khaddafi starts to leave the house. As he does, as audiolog begins to play: "Ya thought you could kill me, boyo?? Nobody fucks with Atlas!"

These are the last words Colonel_Khaddafi hears as the entire house explodes, sweeping him out to sea with the corpse of Captain_Murphy.


Captain_Murphy has been killed. He was -

---

Atlas, Pro-Rapture Vengeful Booby-
Trapped Splicer. You are Atlas, former voice of the people and alias of Frank Fontaine. You were once Rapture’s biggest smuggler and a wanted criminal. Over time, you’ve changed your radical views and have come to realize that stealing isn’t as satisfying as a hard day’s work. You’ve denounced socialism in favor of the free market, and are working to restore your reputation; however, as a former gangster, you refuse to take shit from anyone. If anyone tries to take you down, they’re going down as well.

Passive Ability: If you would be lynched, the person who hammers you also dies. If you would be night killed, the person who kills you also dies.

Colonel_Khaddafi has been killed. He was -

---

Jack, Parasitic One-Shot Assassin Splicer[/b:
27d5mn7p]. As Andrew Ryan’s illegitimate son, you’ve grown sick of living in your father’s shadow. When you arrived in Rapture, nobody gave you the respect you deserved. Earn the respect of the people? Absurd! Why do hard work when you can coast on your father’s legendary name? You’re entitled to Rapture, dammit! Destroy these self-made men and idealistic fools to claim what’s rightfully yours!

Active Ability: Despite being a parasite, you have one additional night kill. You can take your trusty wrench to an unsuspecting citizen’s house and bash their skull in. Sadly, you can only do this once and not until night 2.

It is now day 2. With 9 alive, it's 5 to lynch! Keep on splicin!

[Stardust]

imopen, you got anything?

[Mcdonalds]

Witchhunt, what are your thoughts on what happened during the night?

@stardust: Would you still like an answer to your question from yesterday?

[Mcdonalds]

The irony, Scumbag hates day 1, dies night 1.

[TubeHunter]

Well, at least Captain didn't die in vain..

I would also like to hear from Imopen and witch.

[WitchHunt]

Witchhunt, what are your thoughts on what happened during the night?

@stardust: Would you still like an answer to your question from yesterday?

I'm kind of bummed about CM getting killed, but at least he went out like a champ. Yanni was all over Scumbag, which makes me see him in a bit different light there. Either that or it was one hell of an example for busing. I'm more inclined to believe the prior than the latter.

On the other hand, Kaze needs to claim.

[Mcdonalds]

Curious, who did you target?

[Kazekirimaru]

On the other hand, Kaze needs to claim.

Nope.

imopen, who'd you target?

[WitchHunt]

I targeted imopen2. So I want to know why Kaze was targeting him.

Vote: Kaze

[Kazekirimaru]

You... v.v

Why would you out me like that? If imopen isn't dead(which he isn't) and we are in a role madness game, wouldn't reason suggest via occam's razor that I'm, you know, a town PR?

My goodness...

I did target imopen.

No, I'm not telling you what I am nor my results. At least, not until imopen tells me who he targeted.

[Kazekirimaru]

Actually, fuck it.

I tracked imopen. He targeted Yanni.

[imopen2]

yup, yanni is town

[Kazekirimaru]

Awesome. And so are you

Two confirmed towns(three counting the late Captain) and a scum flip Day 1? Awesome stuff.

Next is analysis. Since Scumbag is confscum, we should look at Day 1 and note his associative tells.

I'll do this some tomorrow when it's not super late.

[Kazekirimaru]

Cool. Let's do this (hopefully I survive the night)

If I die it will be in glorious respect of my great night one death records

lol'd

[( G_R )]

Nice hammer there Tube.

Please tell GR why you shouldn't die toDay?

[WitchHunt]

You... v.v

Why would you out me like that? If imopen isn't dead(which he isn't) and we are in a role madness game, wouldn't reason suggest via occam's razor that I'm, you know, a town PR?

My goodness...

I did target imopen.

No, I'm not telling you what I am nor my results. At least, not until imopen tells me who he targeted.

Right, because after my claim I was really in a position to say, "I'm not going to tell you guys who targeted imopen".

Regardless, I'm satisfied with that for now.

Unvote: Kaze

[quote="Col. Khaddafi » Tue Oct 15, 2013 4:27 pm":
12r3u0yq]Here's a quick attempt at some early reads:

1. Kazekirimaru **: leaning misguided town: He likes to put the pressure and actively hunt/hound people. I think he made a disservice to town by forcing early claims. Its just his style, guy is impulsive
2. Yannaria **: null: Yanni is your regular dumbass which makes it very difficult to read every game
3. G_R **: null: I never saw him play as mafia
4. imopen2 **: null, maybe slightly scum: He is playing his usual "leearning noob" routine. but then he was forced to claim detective, so def. town until day 2
5. DroppinSuga **: null, not enough posting to make a opinion
6. Captain Murphy **: town. been actively scumhunting
7. Tubehunter **: post more
8. Lord_McDonalds **: post more
9. rezombad **: strongly leaning town, not as active as others, but he seems to be paying attention to detail, which i a pro-town thing
10. Colonel Khaddafi **: obvtown
11. RedNihilist **: post more
12. WitchHunt**: town for now, he claimed peeping town, so
lets see his results for day 2[/quote]

Quoted for convenience. Scum had some scarce tells, we'll see what we can do with them.

[rezombad]

His only real vote was for rednihilist before he voted nolynch. Does it smell of bussing?

@Kaze, Yanni, Tubehunter, Witchhunt: do you think a vote for Stardust is a vote for scum?

[TubeHunter]

His only real vote was for rednihilist before he voted nolynch. Does it smell of bussing?

@Kaze, Yanni, Tubehunter, Witchhunt: do you think a vote for Stardust is a vote for scum?

I still think Stardust is town, so I would say no. I don't see the value in bussing that early. Although it is still my second game so

Nice hammer there Tube.

Please tell GR why you shouldn't die toDay?

Mind giving me a reason to other than "he hammered"? You sound grasping for something.

[Kazekirimaru]

I might as well fullclaim now, I suppose. I crumbed it pretty hard.

That's not a false dichotomy as there is 0% chance you are anything other than a scum or a scrub. <3

Did you actually attempt to paint my berating comment towards as a scumtell? Fucking hilarious.


As much as I love jeering at ridiculous scum I have to go make dinner. Lamb sounds pretty good.

Ah, look at all the lonely people~

(A line from The Beatles' "Eleanor Rigby" if you're not familiar.)

WitchHunt be creepin' like a spider.

I am Eleanor Lamb, Pro-Rapture Creeping Spider Splicer.

Being the daughter of Sophia Lamb, I've seen socialism's effects on the Rapture up-close and personally.

As a Spider-Splicer, I can creep around silently and unnoticed. I can silently follow one person per night and find out who they target, if anyone, but not their actions.

[Kazekirimaru]

@Kaze, Yanni, Tubehunter, Witchhunt: do you think a vote for Stardust is a vote for scum?

Not sure quite yet.

[( G_R )]

His only real vote was for rednihilist before he voted nolynch. Does it smell of bussing?

@Kaze, Yanni, Tubehunter, Witchhunt: do you think a vote for Stardust is a vote for scum?

I still think Stardust is town, so I would say no. I don't see the value in bussing that early. Although it is still my second game so

Nice hammer there Tube.
n
Please tell GR why you shouldn't die toDay?

Mind giving me a reason to other than "he hammered"? You sound grasping for something.

Given flips, claims and results revealed so far, and ignoring "the godfather possibility", GR have it narrowed down to four people, you being the only one of them who has brought a hammer. Now kindly answer my question.

[Mcdonalds]

From this I can conclude...

Town
Witchhunter - Unless him and Kaze are pulling some sort of trick (I doubt), kaze confirms he is the watcher, no counterclaim also helps
Kaze - see above, also stop making me think your scum , his claim seems pretty legit as well.
Yanni - Playstyle aside, Scumbags flip makes me see yanni's vote on him as being town motivated.
Stardust - He reached the same conclusion I did day 1 (Lynch me, flip town, Kaze is scum, sheds some light on the others that were on the wagons town 1, although that turns out it was wrong), inclined to think he's town
Rezombad - his graph he posted leads me to believe he's town, and very proactive

Unkown
GR - Need to view his posts more

Scum:
Imopen2: Pending his response to stardust, I am inclined to think he is scum, he's pushing a wagon on a very towny person, with
seemingly out there reasons (I also need to further analyze that mind)
Tubehunter: Was really passive day 1, not a for sure scum read (witchhunt was as well for a large chunk), but I do want to hear more from him

@witchhunt, I think that is more of a quirk of Scumbag's playstyle, not what the scum team is doing (though that may be what they are doing, given the town was focused on lynching me, they may have just let the town simply lynch me and lay low), given the only thing we can really gather from that is that Yanni may be town (barring any sort of bussing going on), it's probably not something we need to read into too much.

[imopen2]

From this I can conclude...

Town
Witchhunter - Unless him and Kaze are pulling some sort of trick (I doubt), kaze confirms he is the watcher, no counterclaim also helps
Kaze - see above, also stop making me think your scum , his claim seems pretty legit as well.
Yanni - Playstyle aside, Scumbags flip makes me see yanni's vote on him as being town motivated.
Stardust - He reached the same conclusion I did day 1 (Lynch me, flip town, Kaze is scum, sheds some light on the others that were on the wagons town 1, although that turns out it was wrong), inclined to think he's town
Rezombad - his graph he posted leads me to believe he's town, and very proactive

Unkown
GR -
Need to view his posts more

Scum:
Imopen2: Pending his response to stardust, I am inclined to think he is scum, he's pushing a wagon on a very towny person, with seemingly out there reasons (I also need to further analyze that mind)
Tubehunter: Was really passive day 1, not a for sure scum read (witchhunt was as well for a large chunk), but I do want to hear more from him

@witchhunt, I think that is more of a quirk of Scumbag's playstyle, not what the scum team is doing (though that may be what they are doing, given the town was focused on lynching me, they may have just let the town simply lynch me and lay low), given the only thing we can really gather from that is that Yanni may be town (barring any sort of bussing going on), it's probably not something we need to read into too much.

I already answered stardust's question.. Yanni is town

[Mcdonalds]

That's a really poor answer all things considered

[TubeHunter]

Given flips, claims and results revealed so far, and ignoring "the godfather possibility", GR have it narrowed down to four people, you being the only one of them who has brought a hammer. Now kindly answer my question.

If you are town I don't know what you intend to get from this incredibly broad question beyond conformation bias. The only answers to it are extremely broad as well, and in no way come to anythnig conclusive. If you want to ask questions fine, but at least ask something productive and non-scummy. Im gonna have to read your posts again.