DERP Mafia Game Over: The Tumor is Benign! Town Win!

[Captain Murphy]

And yes I did slip, I targeted witch with my doc ability and didn't want to spill the beans after I slipped

[Stardust]

[insert standard scum vote miscount above]

Unvote.

Let's finish the mass claim before proceeding.

Stardust - targeted GR
GR - targeted CM
CM - targeted Witch
LMD - no action
imopen?
Suga?

[Stardust]

Let's finish the mass claim before proceeding.

Stardust - targeted GR
GR - targeted CM
CM - targeted Witch
LMD - no action
Wraith?
Suga?

Ugh. Reading too many old games today. Fixed.

[Captain Murphy]

Droppin + wraith + stardust = lynch threshold reached

[Captain Murphy]

But good job calling me scum one more time star

[Captain Murphy]

Droppin + wraith + stardust = lynch threshold reached

+ GR fuck my typos this game

[Wraith223]

Rez! Vote Count please.

[Stardust]

GR unvoted.

[Stardust]

And yes I did slip, I targeted witch with my doc ability and didn't want to spill the beans after I slipped

Wait a sec. You're claiming that you targeted Witch, and you think you killed him. Why did you assume earlier that Kaze had been killed by a town ability?

Vote CM.

Let's finish this game.

[rezombad]

Official Votecount #2.2


Captain Murphy -(3)- DroppinSuga, Stardust, Wraith223


Not Voting -(3)- Lord_Mcdonalds, Captain Murphy, ( G_R )

[DroppinSuga]

I did not take an action the previous night.

Not enough info to safely use it.

[( G_R )]

If CM is scum, Stardust is the jailer-doc and I'm one of the deadly docs, I will... perhaps not laugh, but at list smile about it.

Saying that he did target Witch after all that is very fishy. Let's see if there's another night at all.

Vote Captain Murphy

[rezombad]

Official Votecount #2.3

Captain Murphy -(4)- Lynch! DroppinSuga, Stardust, Wraith223, ( G_R )


Not Voting -(2)- Lord_Mcdonalds, Captain Murphy

-----

The two bodies gave them the evidence they though they needed. The stuttering doctor was surrounded and beaten soundly to within an inch of his life, then again to death.

Captain Murphy has been lynched!

He was:
[spoiler="]Dr. Julius Barber Mafia Goon
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EOGNVgHZ57U[/spoiler]

[rezombad]

Setup:
stardust: Paranoid Doctor is the functional equivalent of a Jailkeeper
droppinsuga: Quack Doctor kills their target instead of protecting them, the functional equivalent of a Vigilante
wraith223: CPR Doctor saves their target from a nightkill, but if the player isn't actually targeted for a nightkill, the CPR Doctor kills them instead.
lmd: Doctor
gr: Naive Doctor does nothing at all
kaze: Weak Doctor dies if it targets a Mafia Goon (and isn't protected themself)

Night1 Actions:
kaze protecting suga (nothing happens)
stardust protecting gr (jailing him)
gr protecting cm (nothing happens lol)
wraith protecting kaze (kill kaze unless kaze is targeted for nightkill)
cm kills witchhunt (mafia nightkill)

[rezombad]

Spec Chat: http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/aruaAgWXAXjU

Scum Chat: http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/vuXFGFn342JPQ

Town MVP: Stardust
Scum MVP: CM

[( G_R )]

[rezombad]

I hope everyone had fun.

[rezombad]

Hi Stardust, You are Doctor Thaddeus S. "Rusty" Venture (The Venture Bros.)
Hi Captain Murphy, You are Dr. Julius Barber (The Misadventures of Flapjack)
Hi Wraith223, You are Dr. Penguin (American Dad)
Hi Kazekirimaru, you are Dr. Franken Stein (Souleater)
Hi ( G_R ), You are Dr. Vindaloo (Courage the Cowardly Dog)
Hi WitchHunt, You are Dr. Krieger (Archer)
Hi DroppinSuga, You are Dr. John A. Zoidberg (Futurama)
Hi Lord_Mcdonalds, You are Dr. Nicholas Riviera M.D. (The Simpsons)
Hi imopen2, You are Dr. Tran (Dr. Tran)

[rezombad]

The reason half of you didn't get the doctors you requested is because in the signup thread I asked for a cartoon doctor.

[DroppinSuga]

I think I was the MVP, fo sho.

[Stardust]

Sweet deal. Good work, GR.

Good game all. Thanks, rezmo.

[Kazekirimaru]

Clean sweep!

Thanks for the game, rez.

[rezombad]

I tried to do votecounts a lot. all the waypoints are in the second post if you haven't gone back there yet.

[imopen2]

Ugh, this game

[Wraith223]

Sorry Kaze. I thought you were scum with CM, and targeted you night 1.

[Wraith223]

Good game, but man was I off day 1 with reads.

[Stardust]

Ugh, this game

Sorry, imopen. Gotta do what you gotta do.

[Wraith223]

@ Stardust, I was not willing to say who I targeted cause I thought you might lynch me.

[Stardust]

Why would I lynch someone who chose to target their scum read? Not claiming, then claiming later would have been far worse.

[Wraith223]

True, but Kaze has a following and people see me as the town idiot. Kaze's aggressive play and weird posts had my radar pinging. The next night I would have targeted Suga if we did not lynch CM. Good learning experience for me.

Apperantly Kaze thinks I will be the death of him.

Self fulfilling prophecy?

[Wraith223]

I was also scared of being hit at from scum thus I figured staying under the radar would be wiser. Also, I don't approve of making unconfirmed claims. Even on myself when I am not in the spot light for lynching.

[rezombad]

1. dont be scared
2. stick to your guns

You changed your vote so many times, I think you voted for everyone at one point on day1.

[Captain Murphy]

My plan was to NK the nurse, and I assumed it was witch so it worked. I knew I was doomed when imopen took the starbait though.

You need to not jump to conclusions so easily when hunting for scum wraith, I swear you called about 6-7 people in this game scum. You will get there though.

[imopen2]

What sucked was I actually felt CM came off very scummy, so it didn't feel like a trap when stardust voted him. I found this set up to be very difficult. Mostly because it was open and I messed up so barely day 1

[Stardust]

You're a difficult player to read, imopen. While it's true that my CM case was made to feel the game out, I wouldn't say it was a trap. Your vote just struck a chord, so I ran with it. Your reaction to that pressure sealed the deal.

[imopen2]

"barely" was supposed to be "terribly"

yea, my reaction was piss poor. I tried to be sly when I should have just argued my reasoning for CM being scum. I think I was at work and didn't check who had voted CM other than me and stardust because I was sure it was lmd but then it was kaze and I panicked. I probably still had a chance to argue my way out but I decided that my death would put CM in a positive light and maybe give him an opportunity to sneak through.

[Kazekirimaru]

Sorry Kaze. I thought you were scum with CM, and targeted you night 1.

Bygones, bygones.

[Kazekirimaru]

This still reigns as my favourite Open setup.

By the way, I had a post restriction where I had to caps rage for 40 words at least once a Day or I'd die. Anyone else have anything like that?

[rezombad]

Nope, just you.

[Stardust]

The next night I would have targeted Suga if we did not lynch CM.

Alright, Wraith, here's the next step in your mafia education. Interactions are extremely powerful. imopen, as scum, would have no reason to offhandedly mention Suga while voting CM Day 1. That was a setup for future days, proven out when imopen flipped scum. That's why Suga was being considered as confirmed town.

Check out posts 94-99, and how imopen talks about CM. That's what scum-on-scum interaction looks like.

I was also scared of being hit at from scum thus I figured staying under the radar would be wiser.

This is something you don't need to be afraid of. As you said, people have been treating you like the town idiot. Lucky for you, you're also easy to read so you're not likely to get lynched. You are getting better, but being the town idiot is not all bad. It means you're never going to be the mafia nightkill target because they'll always target someone who's better at the game. One day you'll get a solid power role like Cop. If you just play it cool in-game, there's no reason why you couldn't get 2 or 3 investigations off since you don't need to worry about dying prematurely.