Gone Postal Mafia - Game Over - Scum Win

[InflatablePie]

and why was your reaction "I didn't ask you anything," rather than listening to your fellow townie when they say you misrep'd and then looking back at your post and the post in question to see where you might have gone wrong? your reaction doesn't feel like very good team-work. it feels like an attempt to bully Jack using a rephrased statement as proof.

somehow missed this post. Went back to check the context and I don't like it. Mostly the tone.

so nvm hooray I caught the scums

Can you be more specific on why you think LMD is scum? Is it because he thinks CM is town?

Lurkiness and bad vote on the hamwagon.

[rezombad]

jack is bothering me though.

[Wraith223]

You always think I'm scum though. Jack is bothering me and I'm going to continue to ask things of him until I'm satisfied.

So your bandwagon failed with Ham and now you vote Jack at random? Either you are throwing Jack under the buss or you just attacking anyone who lurks, not scum hunting, and/or weak targets.

Jack has said some weird shit, but your off the wall vote tops his lurking.

Glad my vote is on you. Why the change/attack on Jack beyond I have said and what you said before? What changed from when you told me my vote was bad on Jack? Are you running interference for CM by throwing out unexplained votes?

[rezombad]

Your vote was on jack was bad. I'm actually trying to get something done. Loaded questions don't get answers.

[InflatablePie]

rez is town for drawing attention to himself with the hamwagon, he's just being bad.

Jack is also town because read his fucking post about the mail system again and ask yourself why the fuck would scum post that.

[imopen2]

rez is town for drawing attention to himself with the hamwagon, he's just being bad.

Jack is also town because read his fucking post about the mail system again and ask yourself why the fuck would scum post that.

So you think Rez is "bad town" but you agree with him on me? He can't be that bad of town then, can he? This feels like when you protected kaze in ragnarok when both of you were scum

[InflatablePie]

rez is bad town because he's voting Jack like a dumbfuck. hence why I posted why Jack is also town: that was directed at Rez for the most part, while saying rez is town was mostly said towards Wraith who is voting rez.

the fact that we're both suspicious of you is irrelevant.

because I can't remember the name of the fallacy but I'm sure it exists: say you have someone protesting things happening in North Korea by eating live scorpions or something and he gets stung or bit or whatever scorpions do, and someone calls him a dumbass. the person calling him a dumbass isn't supporting North Korea by doing so. weird analogy, but you get the idea.

[Stardust]

Official Votecount!

hamfactorial (1): Captain Murphy
DroppinSuga (1): Cursed_Pride
rezombad (2): imopen2, Wraith223
Jack (2): RedNihilist, rezombad
Lord_Mcdonalds (1): InflatablePie

Not voting: Jack, rcwraspy, Lord_Mcdonalds, hamfactorial, DroppinSuga

With 12 alive, it is 7 to lynch.

[Stardust]

Cursed_Pride and hamfactorial have been prodded.

rcwraspy, Jack and RedNihilist will be due for a prod later today. Let's up the activity people! The next time I have to send out multiple prods, it will be with a deadline attached.

[RedNihilist]

This month is hell for me, sorry guys.

[hamfactorial]

I did a re-read of the game with CM in mind but can't find anything to tell me that he's scum. Mostly he just looks like a dick, but that's indicative of nothing at all.

I'm getting bad vibes from LMD for excessive lurking. Last page, both Wraith and Pie suggested that he's on their watch list, and I'm suspicious, too. I equate lurking with scum, as I've mentioned before.

Vote Lord_Mcdonalds

There are others that I'm wary of, too, but I'm going to take the Manders approach and see what they do today before calling them out.

[imopen2]

Pie: your analogy does not fit. You say Rez is bad town, but you share reads on me. That means that the two of you (assuming both are town) have gone through a thought process and come to the same conclusion.

Regardless of whether you were referring to rez's position on jack (you said it was referring to the ham wagon but whatever) the idea that Rez is "bad town" does not mesh with the rest of your analysis (made within the same few posts). Are you bad town for your read on me? Is Rez good town for his read on me? Why would you make a blanket statement and then contradict it only a few posts later?

[rezombad]

Wait.. Are you trying to say pie is bad because he is suspicious of you and said I'm bad while I fingered you?

Because, honestly I did it just to bait and god damn...

[imopen2]

Nope that's not what I'm saying

[imopen2]

I'm not saying HE is bad, I'm saying that doesn't make sense. How can he call you "bad town" (implying 1. That your reads are bad and 2. That you are town) and then agree with your read? He is either agreeing with a bad read or just saying shit he doesn't believe because it's convenient

[rezombad]

So I can't be bad and partially right?

[imopen2]

You could be, but in this case you're not. And it's not that it's not possible, it's that he made such blanket statements "Rez is bad town" "I don't like imopen's tone so he is obv scum." It just doesn't add up to me.

[rezombad]

How can he call you "bad town" ... and then agree with your read?

[imopen2]

What is the point of that quote?

[imopen2]

I honestly feel like I'm playing with scum and then a bunch of lemmings that don't actually want to think about anything for themselves and instead just remain silent. Once I'm dead, you guys are so fucked.

[rezombad]

Wut.

[Jack]

So it seems like most of us share a number of good town reads, but nobody's gained too much lasting attention as a scum suspect.

I'm going to go ahead and Vote Lord_Mcdonalds due to his lack of content from which to draw a town read.
Probably town:
Wraith
Pie
rez
raspy

[rezombad]

Imopen is ridiculous and probbscum
I like lmd for scum, and have since the first page (yeah Obama!)
Jack needs to respond to me
Pie is doing pie things.
Ham is probably fine for now.

Pedit:jack respond to things

[Jack]

What do you want me to respond to? Is it about your alteration of my statement to remove a double negative, and the resulting discussion?

If so, that does change the meaning of my statement. By using a double negative, I expressed that my scum read on him was very weak, and pretty much just suspicion. I said "he could be scum." You said that I said "he's probably not anything other than scum."

[imopen2]

I'm just fed up with how many sheep there are in this game. Since you are scum I can see why it isn't bothering you.

[Stardust]

LMD has requested replacement. If you're reading this thread and are interested in joining in, send me a PM.

[rezombad]

unvote
vote lmd

[Cursed_Pride]

@Mod

If I do not post within 24 hours, feel free to replace me.

I should be able to get a reread of this game done by tomorrow, but no guarantees.

[hamfactorial]

Calling shenanigans on this game

[Stardust]

rcwraspy and Captain Murphy have been prodded.

[rcwraspy]

Prodded. Sorry for the absence been a weird week. Will reread and hopefully find scum later tonight.

[DroppinSuga]

imopen is confirmed town in my eyes. too much rage for a scummer.

[Wraith223]

2 people leaving the game? WTF!

LMD did this in fire and ice. He was scum in that game, and I wonder if he is again?

Iamopen2 is strong town with his good reads on Rez. Where the hell is Catain Murphy? Is he waiting to see if attacks on Rez clear or follow through? He bussed Iamopen2 last game.

So far Rez, CM, and LMD are my scum in that order of strongest reads.

Null due to lack of scum hunting and town posts- Jack, Suga, Red.

Town- Iamopen2, InflateablePie, RCW, and Me

Town- Cursed_Pride

[rezombad]

you forgot ham

[hamfactorial]

Clearly I'm invisible

[rezombad]

imopen is confirmed town in my eyes. too much rage for a scummer.

nah.

lmd is the lynch today, you should be voting for him.

[Mcdonalds]

Stardust convinced me to stay

I also started reading this thread again so that helped

[Mcdonalds]

Not using multiquote as I simply do not have the patience for that

I'm going to go ahead and Vote Lord_Mcdonalds due to his lack of content from which to draw a town read.

Wouldn't this imply you have a lack of content from which to draw a scum read?

[Mcdonalds]

2 people leaving the game? WTF!

LMD did this in fire and ice. He was scum in that game, and I wonder if he is again?

I was never in fire and ice, and if your going to use that as a reason why I am scum, to date I've never actually been scum on this site (I have been a serial killer, although I believe no one was voting me when I replaced out)

[Mcdonalds]

Imopen is ridiculous and probbscum
I like lmd for scum, and have since the first page (yeah Obama!)
Jack needs to respond to me
Pie is doing pie things.
Ham is probably fine for now.

Pedit:jack respond to things

Why weren't you voting me prior to this post then?