Planechase Mafia - Game Over

[hamfactorial]

I'm already in there, bro!

[( G_R )]

I hope you're right. Why do you believe it was a 1-shot deal?

I was under the impression that planeswalking more than once would be a very powerful thing, given that e spent the entire effing day one at it and it was kind of a big deal, except, see the answer to the post bellow.

There's no reason to believe it was a one shot unless it was yours. I could use my secondary walk once per day.

What the hell are you talking about? You had extra walks? Then why the fuck did people lynch imopen2 for? Did I miss where you said something about it before people decided that the only player who hadn't planeswalked was definitely scum because of it, even before he had a chance to prove everyone wrong?

We are so gonna lose this game.

[Manders]

I hope you're right. Why do you believe it was a 1-shot deal?

I was under the impression that planeswalking more than once would be a very powerful thing, given that e spent the entire effing day one at it and it was kind of a big deal, except, see the answer to the post bellow.

There's no reason to believe it was a one shot unless it was yours. I could use my secondary walk once per day.

What the hell are you talking about? You had extra walks? Then why the fuck did people lynch imopen2 for? Did I miss where you said something about it before people decided that the only player who hadn't planeswalked was definitely scum because of it, even before he had a chance to prove everyone wrong?

We are so gonna lose this game.

GR please go look this over. There's something there. WitchHunt is high on my suspicious people list.

[Manders]

Ok here's said list.

Wait, Stardust, why isn't WitchHunt on this list?
Alive
1. Mcdonalds
2. hamfactorial
3. RedNihilist
4. rezombad
5. rcwraspy
6. Pedrobear (replacing TubeHunter)
7. Col. Khaddafi
8. ( G_R )

I'll list them in order shortly.

[Manders]

Town
PedroBear
Hammy
Rezombad
GR
Scumbag
RedNihilist
Mcdonalds
rcwraspy
WitchHunt
Scum

GR's got good evidence of a scum slip because I'm pretty sure he was around for that and said nothing.

[Manders]

That raises an interesting point. If we just blindly planeswalk, there's the risk we will end up in a non-friendly town plane by the time we reach a lynch, having spent all our credits.

So we should ASAP decide who is cleared as town in our game and he should hold its planeswalk as an Ace card in case something bad happens.

This will be Pedrobear for now on.

[Col. Khaddafi]

Manders, WhitcHunt got NightKilled

He's town, he was Karn

[Manders]

Jamie cleared rez, I think he should hold onto the emergency PW.

Remind me how?

[Manders]

Manders, WhitcHunt got NightKilled

He's town, he was Karn

Dammit, that explains that.

He WAS around. Why didn't he say anything, dammit!

[Manders]

Huh I think he said he was camping until Sunday evening a few posts back?

You guys really need to stop being so lazy and just jumping on every train that leaves town

Also rez, how I'm I confirmed Town? I'm missing it too.

Not to mention I could turn Phyrexian by the end of the day.

Did I miss you tell us if this happened or not?

[Manders]

Guess what my intention was with blatantly scummy posts like that and two other ones I made D1 that went uncommented?

And also because he was against me even if I was almost confirmed town.

vote ( G_R )

Did you even read my posts about how I was 99.9% sure that imopen2 didn't walk us away from Orzhov? You were the only other one left at the time, and "almost confirmed town" has won scum many a game.

What's our scum/town ratio right now? Can we afford another mislynch? Don't think so.

Fearmongering, especially since you voted right off the bat Today.

[Manders]

Kpaca why Scumbag?

[Col. Khaddafi]

Lets start by clearing as much people as town.

Dead guys: Can you vouch for any of the remaining people? Manders, do you confirm Ham as town?

[Col. Khaddafi]

Huh I think he said he was camping until Sunday evening a few posts back?

You guys really need to stop being so lazy and just jumping on every train that leaves town

Also rez, how I'm I confirmed Town? I'm missing it too.

Not to mention I could turn Phyrexian by the end of the day.

Did I miss you tell us if this happened or not?

Yeah no I got lucky.

Though I would always say I didn't turn I guess

[Manders]

Lets start by clearing as much people as town.

Dead guys: Can you vouch for any of the remaining people? Manders, do you confirm Ham as town?

I THINK he's Town, but, no, I can't.

[hamfactorial]

Manders didn't have any way to clear me as town. There was nothing special about our bromance chat that made me think she was town, and vice versa.

[Manders]

I even asked...and was told no.

[( G_R )]

Guess what my intention was with blatantly scummy posts like that and two other ones I made D1 that went uncommented?

And also because he was against me even if I was almost confirmed town.

vote ( G_R )

Did you even read my posts about how I was 99.9% sure that imopen2 didn't walk us away from Orzhov? You were the only other one left at the time, and "almost confirmed town" has won scum many a game.

What's our scum/town ratio right now? Can we afford another mislynch? Don't think so.

Fearmongering, especially since you voted right off the bat Today.

Yeah, well, sorry about that. But I'm pretty sure about him. Anyway, we're in LyLo I guess we should mass claim.

I'll start: I'm Vraska the Unseen. If you target me on this plane, you'll lose all abilities including your planeswalk. I warned about this earlier...

[( G_R )]

Ham and Scumbag have already walked this Day, so whenever the private walk boots us from here, it wasn't them.

BTW, this is how io2 got lynched yesterDay.

[Manders]

Ham and Scumbag have already walked this Day, so whenever the private walk boots us from here, it wasn't them.

BTW, this is how io2 got lynched yesterDay.

Making a decision based solely on that is how that happened, but you'd be a fool to ignore evidence.

[( G_R )]

[WitchHunt]

Manders, WhitcHunt got NightKilled

He's town, he was Karn

Dammit, that explains that.

He WAS around. Why didn't he say anything, dammit!

I mentioned a couple times I was fairly sure there were going to be multiple walks in game. In regards to imopen? He wasn't even lynched because of lack of a second walk, he was lynched because he was inactive and scum set it up to look like he had made the private walk. I unvoted and asked for input from LMD and voted him, came back later that night to see io2 was dead. And on that subject, why the fuck are none of you voting LMD? All he's done so far is lurk and vote, he's been on every mislynch wagon. Part of that makes me want to clear GR simply because he was also on his case, I'd need to do a reread of him before I could believe that 100% though.

[Col. Khaddafi]

I'm more than ready to vote McDonalds or rcwraspy based on my rereads and the votes, I'm just holding on my vote because there seems to be a consensus we should hold and discuss stuff for now.

[Manders]

I'm more than ready to vote McDonalds or rcwraspy based on my rereads and the votes, I'm just holding on my vote because there seems to be a consensus we should hold and discuss stuff for now.

See, shit like this makes you look guilty.

And they are not voting LMD, WitchHunt, because they have got to put in some work. Yeah, I'm pretty sure he's scum as well, but we can't afford to be wrong in this.

[Manders]

BTW I texted kpaca and told him we could talk. I guess he still doesn't have time for it.

[Stardust]

You are currently on Ravnica, at Orzhova.

Votecount

( G_R ) (1): Pedrobear

Not voting: Mcdonalds, hamfactorial, RedNihilist, rezombad, Col. Khaddafi, rcwraspy, ( G_R )

With 8 alive, it's 5 to lynch.

[Stardust]

Pedrobear has been prodded.

[Pedrobear]

I'll stay there for emergency planeswalking. Still trying to understand what was the scenario of Night 1 when I did got silenced (not me, but Tube).

unvote

[hamfactorial]

In the interest of more information being better, I'll claim.

I'm Koth of the Hammer. I have no abilities, but I can chat with my neighbor Manders who was killed N1. I used my Spellbreaker ability on Pedrobear today, since he's mod-confirmed town.

[Pedrobear]

I'm Gideon, I can redirect any bad ability during Night from a target to me.
Used on ria on Night1
Got silenced for Night2
Used on Rez on Night3

[Pedrobear]

I have no explanation on why Tube used it on Ria during Night 1. But for my part, it felt like Rez was probably going to be the target of something due to his active scum hunting.

[Manders]

He probably chose ria for the same reasons you chose Rez.

Does your role PM actually specify it stops bad abilities?

[Pedrobear]

Yes.

[Manders]

Interesting...

[imopen2]

i think lmd and red are scum..not sure of the last one. sorry i haven't been active and that it cost us a lynch. i just took the lsat today and its been a busy month studying, going to gp vegas, camping etc.

i agree with manders that we need lmd (and red for that matter) to talk more before we settle on the lynch. there's too much at stake to rush to a conclusion. lets see those T/S lists!!

[( G_R )]

Pedro, you didn't need to claim.

[hamfactorial]

Town:
Pedrobear
Rez
GR

Null:
RedN

Scum:
Col K
McDonalds
Raspy

Red is the lurkiest lurker who ever did lurk, which is really screwing with my read of the game. He could be scum or just town mailing it in.

Col K is my weakest scum read. If he was town, he may be infected now, but eliminating scum is the priority over 3rd faction hunting.

Between those 3, McDonalds is my preferred lynch but it's entirely gut plus some influence from Col K's vote records showing him voting everyone all the time.

[Pedrobear]

That was just a statement of the obvious.

I have the same gut for McDonalds. I just reread his posts, some were obvious answer questions and tried to corner people with it. If I were scum that what I would also do.

[Pedrobear]

And on the lynch on Jamie, he was the last one to vote

[Jamie]

I don't think the hammer on me is very telling because a day1 lynch on a town is probably better than a day1 no-lynch, and we were really pressed for time and it was either me or nobody.