Planechase Mafia - Game Over

[rcwraspy]

planeswalk

4th anniversary this weekend so not going to contribute much, sorry for the prolonged absence. Come Sunday night or Monday I should be able to do a re-read.

[( G_R )]

I think I'll save my walk for an emergency, we don't want to be stuck in mob town.

[Stardust]

planeswalk

You are now on Innistrad. If a player dies on Innistrad, they will become a ghost. Ghosts may post at any time in either the game thread or factional quicktopics, but cannot vote or use any other abilities.

[Stardust]

rezombad has been prodded.

Since none of imopen2, TubeHunter and rianalnn have picked up their prods let alone posted here, I'd normally be aiming to replace them at this point. I'll give them (and rezombad) until Monday. Hopefully we can avoid a mass modkilling, but I'll do it if I have to.

[hamfactorial]

Can we stay in this plane? It's extremely pro-town.

[Mcdonalds]

We wouldn't want another rage quit

[Mcdonalds]

That aside, what are we doing, I feel there is a solid case on scumbag, is there anyone Im missing, what do?

[hamfactorial]

I don't see the case on Scumbag, just a few early day pile-on votes. If we're going to lynch him for some reason, it should definitely be done here on Innistrad, though.

[imopen2]

I've been quite busy, and this new forum upgrade makes phone-posting a chore. I'm still waiting for scumbag to post a t/s. I don't like all the pile-on votes that followed my initial one, though.

This game seems to have come to something of a halt, but I do agree that this plane is pro-town and we should stay here.

[Col. Khaddafi]

I didn't forgot about the T/S list, hopefully this w/E I'll have time to complete my reread.

[WitchHunt]

With this said Planeswalking is the way to go. First it makes for a fun game, second, as town we can glean some more info, think Serra's realm.

Plus, reading the OP, if we can get to Grixis, we might bring back a zombie Manders, no idea how this works, but it seems we have a limited capability to revive townies... So lets keep up with the momentum.

This is true. @Stardust If we did manage to end back up on Grixis and bring someone back to life as a zombie with their alignment unchanged, do they retain the abilities they had before death?

[Stardust]

As it says in the plane description, they lose and can't gain any abilities.

[rianalnn]

We werent doing anything so I started lurking I guess.

[Col. Khaddafi]

Well, unsurprisingly I haven't had the time for a full T/S list, but I'll post an abridged version to get things moving

Town.

hamfactorial: The bromance thing settles it. I don't see any workable scenario where lovers (is that the mafia term?) would be town-scum or town-neutral, plus flavorgaming makes it unlikely ham is anything less than town, since he is likely Elspeth or Koth. 99% town

rezombad. Active. Scumhunting: strongly leaning town

Witchhunt: Ditto. Have a good vibe about his posts. strongly leaning town too.

rianalnn: came up with the planeswalk plan which is a solid pro-town strategy. Said Bolas realm was pro-town, but I highly doubt this is a gambit. Was fairly active, now is lurking but hey, so is everyone. Also strongly leaning town

imopen2: has made a token effort of coming up with partial T/S lists over the game: leaning town

Tubehunter: wans't cleared town in Serra's realm (50% chance of it). Othewise, active scumhunting. slightly leaning town (because of the 50% thingy)

rcwraspy: tending null, made a nice PBPA of Tubehunter

RedNihilist: ditto, not much to read about, most he did was questioning ria's statement about Bolas realm being protown.

( G_R ): not much to read on. A little scumhunting. Null

McDonalds: mostly lurking or making null posts. Leaning scum

Scum

[Col. Khaddafi]

Btw, Stardust deleted it, but the post isolation link is:

search.php?st=0&sk=t&sd=d&sr=posts&t=32 ... sf=msgonly

replace witchhunt by the user you want

[rezombad]

You guys need to stop modgaming.

Explain yourself.

Just because they're neighbors doesn't mean that he's town or scum and shouldn't be used as the sole reason for clearing him as town.

I want a t/s list from you, red.

And until I get one I'm going to:

vote rednihilist

[Stardust]

Victoria Day holiday today. Back tomorrow to settle thing and I'll extend the deadline as well.

[rezombad]

planeswalk

4th anniversary this weekend so not going to contribute much, sorry for the prolonged absence. Come Sunday night or Monday I should be able to do a re-read.

Fuck the reread, post something.

[rezombad]

That aside, what are we doing, I feel there is a solid case on scumbag, is there anyone Im missing, what do?

What's the case against scumbag? I must've missed it.

[rezombad]

We werent doing anything so I started lurking I guess.

Stop smoking tons of blunts while wishing you were at an incubus concert and play more of this game.

[rezombad]

planeswalk

This walk from lorwn (night lasts a hard 24 hours) pings.

[Stardust]

PedroBear replaces TubeHunter. Thanks for filling in and welcome to the game!

[Stardust]

Btw, Stardust deleted it, but the post isolation link is:

search.php?st=0&sk=t&sd=d&sr=posts&t=32 ... sf=msgonly

replace witchhunt by the user you want

A couple things got messed up in the first post for some reason. The link is back there now.

[Stardust]

You are currently on Innistrad.

Votecount

Col. Khaddafi (4): imopen2, rianalnn, Mcdonalds, RedNihilist
WitchHunt (1): ( G_R )
RedNihilist (1): rezombad

Not voting: hamfactorial, rcwraspy, Col. Khaddafi, WitchHunt, PedroBear

With 11 alive, it's 6 to lynch.


Deadline extended to one week + 4 hours from the time of this post, 12:00 noon MST, Tuesday May 26. Deadline Clock.

[WitchHunt]

That aside, what are we doing, I feel there is a solid case on scumbag, is there anyone Im missing, what do?

What's the case against scumbag? I must've missed it.

Seconded, the case against him was super minor imo. Maybe he knows something we don't?

[hamfactorial]

Let's lynch someone. Lynch me if you like, I'd enjoy being a spooky ghost and shooting ectoplasm everywhere.

[RedNihilist]

You guys need to stop modgaming.

Explain yourself.

Just because they're neighbors doesn't mean that he's town or scum and shouldn't be used as the sole reason for clearing him as town.

I want a t/s list from you, red.

And until I get one I'm going to:

vote rednihilist

As you wish.

Prob. town:
hamfactorial
imopen2

Grey area:
( G_R )
Col. Khaddafi
McDonalds
rezombad
rianalnn

Leaning scum:
WitchHunt
rcwraspy
BearHunter

Now, please explain me why do you care so much about the way I evaluate ham.
He's by far the towniest player in this game even if we ignore the whole bromance thing that seems to bother you so much, so I don't really get what your problem is.
Do you read him as scum?
Have you got some implicit statement?
Are you just trying to keep us from doing any kind of PoE?

Enlighten me, please.

[rezombad]

Posts that are worthless:

---

I didn't get my first choice.

I'd like you guys to stop planeswalking randomly, some planes could be dangerous.

Yup, that would be awful.
Still I fear that some planes could be ACTUALLY dangerous.

Now I'm fucking vanilla and will remain such likely the whole game. Thanks.

We're probably going to visit planes more than once at this rate, don't worry.

What's the point in bashing him?

Oh God.

DK be a good boy and come back.

*first 5 posts, not super damning as they all took place at the beginning of the game over 3 days.*

posts that dont appear worthless at first:

---

Vote rialnann

Seriously, how does

"You are now at Bolas's Metitation Realm. Any player not voting at the end of the Day will be untargetable for that Night. Mafia members also - mmmph!"

qualify as "Town"?

He doesnt unvote kpaca after kpaca explains his position on bolas' meditation realm. And then asks kpaca a follow up question that he doesnt care to get answered and leaves his vote on kpaca.

So, let's keep going.
PLaneswalk

k.

Can I get a little bit of time before we pw away?
Thanks!

This post is interesting because were almost 250 posts in to the game, and you have no inkling for who could be town.

Jeez, thanks for giving me the time to think about my Esper-related ability.

and since we were planeswalking all over the place anyway we were probably oing to leave esper.

Feel free to follow up with any motivation for that.

On a side note, is it time for a mass prod?

direced at me for voting rcwraspy. I should probably check in on him.

-----

I don't really see TH as scum, I'll try to reread his posts though.

holy shit an opinion. 350 posts in and you actually take a stance on something, sort of, not really, but it's close. It really says 'I'm trying to look town'

-----

Raspy's case is good, but I'm still not sold on that.
That TBH thing is not something I'd rely upon, and the "Bolas meditation realm is protown" thing was the very reason thatmade me vote for kpaca, but nobody seemed to care at the time.
Not tha

The only person that interacted with this post is manders as far as I can tell.

-----

Unvote

unvoting the replacement, k.
-----
MORE WORTHLESS POSTS

Lets be honest I would never come up with that plan as scum.

LoL

Gratz you scummy faker

-----

gah.. i have to leave for work, ill get the other couple of posts later.





tl;dr red hasn't done anything but is doing a fair amount of it. The things that bother me are the things that look like they would be town, but are off: the esper thing, the vote for kpaca, the inability to take a stance on something.

[imopen2]

you make good points, rez, and i will be leaving for a canoe trip tomorrow and won't be back till tuesday, so i'll trust you and

Unvote

Vote: Red

[rezombad]

planeswalk

[hamfactorial]

Why?

[rezombad]

Since he's scum It does us no good to let red continue to talk after we lynch him

[hamfactorial]

Who's going to listen to a dead scum ghost?

[rezombad]

They do get to post in their factional quick topic as well

[Stardust]

planeswalk

You are now on Mercadia. The player who planeswalked here has their voting strength increased by 1 for the remainder of the Day. This will not be reflected in the votecount. The votes needed to lynch this Day are increased by 1 vote.

[Stardust]

You are currently on Mercadia.

Votecount

Col. Khaddafi (3): rianalnn, Mcdonalds, RedNihilist
WitchHunt (1): ( G_R )
RedNihilist (2): rezombad, imopen2

Not voting: hamfactorial, rcwraspy, Col. Khaddafi, WitchHunt, PedroBear

With 11 alive plus the effect of Mercadia, it's 7 to lynch.


Deadline in 5 days. Deadline Clock.

[Stardust]

Mcdonalds, rcwraspy, rianalnn, Col. Khaddafi and ( G_R ) have all been prodded.

[Mcdonalds]

So to clarify, that persons vote counts for 2?

[( G_R )]

Vote rezombad

A townie would never be so certain as to completely eliminate the possibility of having a mislynched townie stick around as a ghost.

[( G_R )]

Plus keeping a scum ghost would only be an opportunity to have them slip.