[Fedoras of Salvation] - White Knights ITT

[LP, of the Fires]

To Chapin and his opponents credit, they are working the verbal play impressively.

[Thrillho]

"We have it on tape."

[Valdarith]

Chapin's big argument should be that the order of the cards in his hand never changed, therefore it is easy to deduce what card he picked up from Ajani.

[Thrillho]

this video needs the NYPD Blue theme.

[LP, of the Fires]

You can feel Chapin relapsing to his gangster days.

"Oh you don't have the ability to downgrade? Downgrade this mothafucka!"

[Thrillho]

Chapin's big argument should be that the order of the cards in his hand never changed, therefore it is easy to deduce what card he picked up from Ajani.

yeah absolutely. but he's under a lot of pressure and also tilted to some extradimensional level, so he's going in every direction with this rules lawyering.

[Thrillho]

"gangster days"
aka some skinny white kid rolling on molly at raves.

[LP, of the Fires]

To be fair, this is what the ruling should be.

[Valdarith]

It is. It sucks. I hope he doesn't lose another match.

[Thrillho]

To be fair, this is what the ruling should be.

rulzRrulz, and i agree. it doesn't make for compelling video tho, and there's clear ability to undo the illegal game state.

michele looks so salty for someone who got a free game win.

[Kaitscralt]

could someone say what happen in abridged form for people who are working

[Valdarith]

Chapin ticked up Ajani, saw Tasigur, put it on top of his hand without revealing, then picked the cards up slowly without changing their order. Got game loss for drawing without revealing.

[Thrillho]

chapin and his opponent were in turns in abzan control mirror, both 5-0
each player has elspeth in play with 3 tokens. chapin has ugin on 10 and ajani, mentor of heroes.
chapin pump-fakes ultimate ugin
chapin +1s ajani for his pwalker/creature ability, finds a tasigur and *without revealing it* puts it face-down on top of his hand
table judge calls him and issues a game loss
chapin appeals
head judge maintains penalty

[Thrillho]

Chapin ticked up Ajani, saw Tasigur, put it on top of his hand without revealing, then picked the cards up slowly without changing their order. Got game loss for drawing without revealing.

he never picked up the cards, the cards remained face down on the table.
the head judge later clarified that face down on the table or in his hand facing him are one in the same regarding placement of cards, where because the cards were touching after activating the ability, they became his hand, and he therefore the card entered his hand w/o revealing it.

[Thrillho]

also what's tabbed browsing, precious?

[LP, of the Fires]

He basically grabs tasigur, puts it facedown, the card touched his hand, as he's putting cards on bottom of library, opponent reminds Pat that he has to reveal it.

Was like, the second time it happened in the match btw, but this time, it actually touched his hand.

[Thrillho]

and the feed crashes.

[Kaitscralt]

it's truly amazing I haven't turned the stream on my phone and burned through my data plan

[Kaitscralt]

usually that's my MO for PT friday

[Valdarith]

Chapin ticked up Ajani, saw Tasigur, put it on top of his hand without revealing, then picked the cards up slowly without changing their order. Got game loss for drawing without revealing.

he never picked up the cards, the cards remained face down on the table.
the head judge later clarified that face down on the table or in his hand facing him are one in the same regarding placement of cards, where because the cards were touching after activating the ability, they became his hand, and he therefore the card entered his hand w/o revealing it.

I'm pretty sure he actually did end up picking up his hand, but it was very brief.

Also, LOL at Nam Sung Wook desperately searching for a Retraction Helix in one turn. Awesome.

[Thrillho]

i know what i saw.

[Valdarith]

We'll have to wait for it to be posted on the Utubes then.

[Kaitscralt]

I trust his eyes with my life

[Valdarith]

Then your life is forfeit!

[windstrider]

You know what, fuck it. I kinda like the deck I brewed up. At this point, I just want to play something fun and interesting and not worry about what everyone else is doing.

[Kaitscralt]

caj

[Khaospawn]

The laces were in!!!

[nme]

The worst part of the pt randy beuler. Listening to that guy is pure suffering.

[Kaitscralt]

you're not wrong

[Thrillho]

he's the only commentator who actually knows what's going on

[Valdarith]

Virulent Plague is REALLY annoying.

[Thrillho]

lp you missed your chance to put the money in your mouth as atarka is sold out on tcgplayer.

[windstrider]

caj

Yeah. Don't really care.

[Thrillho]

I would also like to point out that you called Secure the Wastes and I haven't seen a copy played during the coverage so far.

[Thrillho]

you've been a great help.

[Thrillho]

I'm sure Secure the Wastes' mother is very proud regardless.

[Thrillho]

Has Yasooka been on camera multiple times or is every Japanese player casting promo Ugins?

[Thrillho]

I tip my hat to Yasooka regardless.

[Thrillho]

Nice Narset, asshole.

[Thrillho]

The worst part of the pt randy beuler. Listening to that guy is pure suffering.

marshall suitecliff just declared "duress" as "foul tongue invocation" during the standard portion of day 1.