Kaze's Newbie Mafia (Mafia Win)

[Kazekirimaru]

Thanks for playing, everyone! I hope you had an enjoyable time.

[rcwraspy]

Thanks for the fun game everybody!

[Stardust]

Yea, I knew stardust was scum once the lynch was in on Tubehunter because he started making no sense. Well hopefully this served as a good first game for some people. You played very well, dusty

Thanks. Goes to show that you sometimes can't trust the honest cases either. Like I said in the very beginning of this game, townies act scummy too. There's rarely a need for scum to lie.

When did I start making no sense?

Night 3 actions:
Checkbox Jailkeeps imopen2(Successful - No effect)
Stardust kills Checkbox(Successful)

imopen! Wow, rcw was righter than I was. I figured he'd be off your radar completely. But I guess you never did trust that first gambit, did you Checkbox?


Shout out to rcw for doing a pretty damn fine job for his first time as scum too. It's
tough not to crack under pressure in your first game, and you did very well at that despite some dubious strategic choices Day 2. Good work. You rock.

[imopen2]

Stardust: see iso's posts in response to yours after the lynch. Also, the way you said "you know what to do checkbox" when we were pretty much screwed and also telling checkbox to reveal which way he was leaning on his jailing ability. At that point is was too late tho

[Checkbox]

Noooooooooooooooooo I was right all along!!!

[Checkbox]

I strongly.considered getting stardust for a third straight time... Ugh gg tho

[TubeHunter]

All of my

[Checkbox]

The town just got caught up in seeing newbie play as scummy. Ugh

[Checkbox]

@imopen: it wasn't too late, I said rcw but I never really intended on jailing him, though he was a scum read of mine. I went back and forth between stardust for a third time, rce for being so obviously scummy with the hammer, and you with your "are we following stardust off a cliff? Oh well lets see what happens"

I might've taken heed of your word if you had mentioned that stardust was scum after the lynch

[TubeHunter]

Sorry checkbox, I panicked and got major conformation bias blinded. Everything you did made me think you were scum. I blame this on me. I would've thrown anyone under the bus to not get lynched day 2 and ended up saying a lot of stupid shit. I got my act together later but some holes you can't climb out of.

[rcwraspy]

Checkbox, I was actually hoping you'd jail me. That hammer was the most obviously scummy thing anybody had done all game. I didn't post a single thing after my hammer because I didn't want to mess up how Stardust was leading the conversation. At that point I didn't want to give any doubt that I was scum, but I wasn't about to come out and actually declare it.

[imopen2]

I was serious when I said use a random number generator to pick. There was too much "WIFOM" involved and I didn't want to confuse things further since I wasn't sure if iso was his scum partner or not. Then kaze said no more post

[rcwraspy]

Then kaze said no more post

Then Iso posted

[Iso]

-_-

CHEEECKBOOOX. You shoulda Jailed Stardust!

I had a case pending against Stardust and everything for when Day opened.

[Iso]

I'll get you in next week's episode, Stardust.

[rcwraspy]

Well, to be fair to Checkbox:

Jail Stardust if TubeHunter is scum. If not, then it's 50% between who you think the two scum are.

Tube obviously flipped Town. If I were Checkbox after Tube flipped, I probably would have taken this as "jail 33% Stardust"

Iso, you're a force to be reckoned with, aren't you! It was fun trying to poke the bear and then having to run away.

[TubeHunter]

still, nice game, wish I coulve played a bit better than i did though, but live and learn.

[Iso]

Heh, thanks. I was mad at myself when TubeHunter flipped town because I should have picked up on Stardust WAY sooner, but it was only until I realized he was attempting to set me up all along that I caught on. And I shouldn't have stopped pushing rcw just because I wasn't convinced by my own case. D<

[imopen2]

Yea, iso! You didn't carry us to victory like you were supposed to >_<

[Stardust]

I'll get you in next week's episode, Stardust.

Have we ever been on the same team?

[rcwraspy]

I'll get you in next week's episode, Stardust.

Have we ever been on the same team?

haha that sounds like an auto RVS to me.

[Iso]

I was rooting for you in Lucian, if that counts

But no, I don't believe we have been. You've been scum in all of my games. :weird:

Also, as soon as you mentioned my case against rcw being unfair, I knew I should've pounced on you. >:[

I need to stop ignoring my gut.

[rcwraspy]

your initial case on me, or your response to my case on you?

[Stardust]

I was rooting for you in Lucian, if that counts

But no, I don't believe we have been. You've been scum in all of my games. :weird:

Also, as soon as you mentioned my case against rcw being unfair, I knew I should've pounced on you. >:[

I need to stop ignoring my gut.

Ah, Lucian. What a heart-breaking game.

You were scum in Boondocks, so it's not always my fault. We were actually on the same team in King of the Hill, but that lasted, what, a week?

[Iso]

your initial case on me, or your response to my case on you?

Oh right, my response to your case. That one.

I was rooting for you in Lucian, if that counts

But no, I don't believe we have been. You've been scum in all of my games. :weird:

Also, as soon as you mentioned my case against rcw being unfair, I knew I should've pounced on you. >:[

nI need to stop ignoring my gut.

Ah, Lucian. What a heart-breaking game.

You were scum in Boondocks, so it's not always my fault. We were actually on the same team in King of the Hill, but that lasted, what, a week?

You have only yourself to blame for how Lucian turned out.

And PSH.

Wait, you were town in KotH? I don't quite recall that.

[Stardust]

You have only yourself to blame for how Lucian turned out.

Never!

Wait, you were town in KotH? I don't quite recall that.

Terrible town, but town nonetheless. Remember that awesome gambit I ran where I lied about Tom to prove he was scum by drawing the opposite conclusion I should have based entirely on meta arguments and it turned out he was actually town even after he fell into my trap! Wow!
Good play, Stardust!

(That was my first town game... I still like running gambits, but at least they make sense these days. At least, they make sense most of the time... I hope. )

[RedNihilist]

Noooooooooooooooooo I was right all along!!!

That's why you killed me rather than pushing on raspy?

[Clownfish]

Wow, that went quickly! At same point in the beginning of day two, I was seriously considering casing Stardust. Not because I felt like he was scum, but because I felt like he hadn't been under any scrutiny himself, and it felt like we couldn't win if Scumdust kept flying under the radar. Then I completely disregarded that because I felt like other people were acting way more scummy. I feel like such a rube...

[Stardust]

Live and learn. You played well, Clownfish. Anytime the mafia choose to kill someone who's not confirmed town, that person should be proud.